Visit your Brooklyn Pet Store located at 2343 Utica Ave for all of your animal nutrition, pet supplies and grooming needs. Our mission at Petco is Healthier Pets. Happier People.
Many customers praised the staff for being friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful, although some reported issues with unresponsive employees.
Grooming Services
Grooming services received mixed reviews, with some customers expressing satisfaction while others reported poor experiences and unprofessional behavior.
Product Availability
Customers frequently mentioned issues with stock availability, particularly for specific pet food items, leading to frustration.
Store Cleanliness
The cleanliness of the store was noted positively by some, while others reported unpleasant odors and unkempt areas.
Pricing Concerns
Several reviews indicated that customers found prices to be high, which affected their overall satisfaction.
UB
Uvraj Boodhoo
2 days ago
4.0
Quality products at affordable prices
NG
Nadine Guillaume
Jan 4, 2026
4.0
Never stocked as well as other location (86 & Lexington or Broadway and 91st) but friendly staff and clean. Please give them a few more carts, they probably have about 10 in total.
CL
Chris Lee
Jan 3, 2026
5.0
I’ve been going to this Petco since it opened up years ago. But I’ve recently been going more over the past few years. This location in Brooklyn is one of the most kindest and friendliest that I’ve ever been too. They’re constantly updating and striving to meet goals and you can tell. Customer service is top notch and they build great rapport with their clients. They are normally well stocked and the animals are very healthy and friendly with great dispositions. They are handled well, with care, and the staff often has animals of their own, so they understand empathy and are very knowledgeable of both human and animal care. That’s more important in today’s world and it’s a privilege to see how Petco is honouring that relationship and bond while upgrading as the world turns. Thank you all at this location for being a light in the neighborhood. It’s well received and we appreciate you for all you do for us and our furry families. Happy New Year and may your business and staff be abundantly blessed. 🙏🏽♥️🌹✨
BM
betty marrero
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
Close location for me. They had what i needed and staff was helpful.
KK
Kathy Kelly
Dec 18, 2025
3.0
Elevator was down so no one would bring stock down. My cats need special food which I could not get. PRICES ARE WAY TO HIGH
Does the Petco Old Mill Basin location have a vet hospital?
No, Petco Old Mill Basin does not have a full-service vet hospital.
Does Petco Old Mill Basin offer vaccinations?
Yes, Petco Old Mill Basin provides vaccinations.
Does Petco Old Mill Basin offer curbside pickup?
Yes, curbside pickup is available at Petco Old Mill Basin. All of our products that are eligible for store pickup will show this option on the product's detail page.
How much are hamsters and guinea pigs at Old Mill Basin Petco?
Hamster and guinea pig prices vary by location. Call your Old Mill Basin Petco at 7183383896 to check for pricing and availabilty in your store. Or visit ourcompanion animal website for more information on small companion animals.
Does Petco Old Mill Basin sell dogs?
No, Old Mill Basin Petco does not sell dogs or cats. However, with the Petco Love program partnered with local animal welfare organizations, you have the opportunity to meet dogs and cats available for adoption at your neighborhood Petco store.
Where is the Petco store located in Old Mill Basin?
The Petco store is located at 2343 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234.
What are the operating hours of Petco Old Mill Basin?
Petco Old Mill Basin is open every day from 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
Does Petco Old Mill Basin offer vaccination services for pets?
Yes, Petco Old Mill Basin provides vaccination services for pets.
Does Petco Old Mill Basin have a full-service veterinary hospital?
No, this location does not have a full-service veterinary hospital.
Can I get curbside pickup at Petco Old Mill Basin?
Yes, curbside pickup is available for eligible products at Petco Old Mill Basin.
Does Petco Old Mill Basin sell dogs or cats?
No, this Petco location does not sell dogs or cats but partners with local organizations for pet adoptions.
What payment methods are accepted at Petco Old Mill Basin?
Petco Old Mill Basin accepts credit cards, debit cards, and mobile NFC payments. Cash is not required.
Are there accessible facilities available at Petco Old Mill Basin?
Yes, the store has wheelchair accessible parking, entrance, and restroom.
Which nearby restaurants can I visit before or after shopping at Petco Old Mill Basin?
Nearby dining options include Popeyes® Louisiana Kitchen, Burger King, Dunkin', Mandarin House, Baskin-Robbins, and Floridian Plaza Diner.
What public transportation options are available near Petco Old Mill Basin?
MTA bus lines B9, B41, B41LTD, Q35, and the NYCT B2 at Avenue S/Flatbush Avenue bus stations are nearby for easy access to Petco.
Are there veterinary services near Petco Old Mill Basin for specialized pet care?
Yes, the Vetco Vaccination Clinic and another Petco location with veterinary services are nearby for additional pet care needs.