Visit your Brooklyn Pet Store located at 2601 86th Street for all of your animal nutrition, pet supplies and grooming needs. Our mission at Petco is Healthier Pets. Happier People.
Many customers praised the friendly and helpful staff, while others reported negative experiences with unprofessional behavior and poor service.
Product Availability
Customers frequently noted limited stock, particularly in the cat section, and issues with online order fulfillment.
Grooming Services
Mixed reviews on grooming services, with some customers expressing satisfaction while others reported poor experiences and dissatisfaction with the results.
Store Condition
The store received positive feedback for cleanliness and renovations, but some customers mentioned disorganization and unpleasant odors.
LL
Laura
6 days ago
3.0
This store always seems to be under staffed. Never has the parakeets supplies I need. Prices are ridiculous.
TI
thomas irizarry
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
That was the fastest I have gotten a delivery.
BK
Bracha Kritzler
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
Awesome experience! I bought a turtle for my class and was helped by the sweetest saleslady (I think her name was Kemo?). She helped me every step of the way, showing me everything I needed, helped me decide what to buy, etc. And she was smiling and so happy to help, it made the buying experience a pleasure! Also, my students are absolutely loving our turtle! Would definitely recommend petco to anyone looking to purchase a pet...
BC
Besik Chkhikvadze
Dec 26, 2025
1.0
Visited the Petco at 2601 86th St, Brooklyn for a Vetco consultation with five very small kittens (just over 1 lb each). Staff required me to purchase three additional carriers and confirmed twice before purchase that they could be returned afterward.
After the Vetco consultation, no vaccinations or medical procedures were performed because the kittens were under 2 lb. The carriers were used for only a few minutes, remained clean, undamaged, and fully resalable, and I immediately attempted to return them.
The return was refused by the manager, who claimed the carriers were “used at Vetco,” could not show any written policy, and became dismissive. When I asked for clarification, the manager threatened to call the police, which was completely inappropriate. I remained calm and was eventually forced to leave the store without resolution.
This experience was extremely disappointing due to misinformation from staff, lack of transparency, and unprofessional manager conduct. I am currently seeking resolution through Petco corporate.
TR
Tatiana Rubas
Dec 22, 2025
4.0
Overall everything is fine, the staff is nice and all, but there are very limited options of cat items. It seems like there are 3-5 times more variety of dog toys and snacks at all times. I always want to get some new toy for my cats, but there are mostly 3-5 varieties of chasers and a couple of packets with various balls. Not much to choose from for cats.
Does the Petco Bensonhurst location have a vet hospital?
No, Petco Bensonhurst does not have a full-service vet hospital.
Does Petco Bensonhurst offer vaccinations?
Yes, Petco Bensonhurst provides vaccinations.
Does Petco Bensonhurst offer curbside pickup?
Yes, curbside pickup is available at Petco Bensonhurst. All of our products that are eligible for store pickup will show this option on the product's detail page.
How much are hamsters and guinea pigs at Bensonhurst Petco?
Hamster and guinea pig prices vary by location. Call your Bensonhurst Petco at 7182661206 to check for pricing and availabilty in your store. Or visit ourcompanion animal website for more information on small companion animals.
Does Petco Bensonhurst sell dogs?
No, Bensonhurst Petco does not sell dogs or cats. However, with the Petco Love program partnered with local animal welfare organizations, you have the opportunity to meet dogs and cats available for adoption at your neighborhood Petco store.
What services does Petco Bensonhurst offer for pet care?
Petco Bensonhurst provides premium pet foods, expert training, and vaccination services to help keep your pets happy and healthy.
Does Petco Bensonhurst have a veterinary hospital on site?
No, there is no full-service veterinary hospital at the Petco Bensonhurst location.
Can I pick up my online Petco order curbside at the Bensonhurst store?
Yes, curbside pickup is available for eligible products ordered online at Petco Bensonhurst.
What are the opening hours of Petco Bensonhurst?
Petco Bensonhurst is open every day from 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
Does Petco Bensonhurst sell dogs and cats for adoption?
Petco Bensonhurst does not sell dogs or cats. However, through the Petco Love program with local animal welfare organizations, you can meet pets available for adoption at the store.
What are the payment options available at Petco Bensonhurst?
Petco Bensonhurst accepts credit cards, debit cards, and mobile NFC payments.
Is Petco Bensonhurst accessible for customers with disabilities?
Yes, the store has wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, and restroom facilities to accommodate customers with disabilities.
Are there any nearby pet services around Petco Bensonhurst that I can visit?
Yes, Just Food For Dogs is a nearby pet service you can visit for additional pet nutrition needs, and there is also another Petco Bensonhurst location offering dog training services close by.
What dining options are available near Petco Bensonhurst for a meal before or after shopping?
Near Petco Bensonhurst, you can enjoy meals at John's Deli, Skinny Greek vegetarian restaurant, Daddy’s Pizza & Pasta, and Chequito’s Mexican Food And Pizzeria among other dining spots.
What nearby stores can I visit for electronics or mobile phone needs when I come to Petco Bensonhurst?
Total Wireless and T-Mobile stores nearby offer mobile phone services and accessories, while Fast Global Phone Accessories provides electronics and fashion accessories.