Visit your Bay Shore Pet Store located at 1851 Sunrise Highway for all of your animal nutrition, pet supplies and grooming needs. Our mission at Petco is Healthier Pets. Happier People.
Feedback on staff is mixed; while many customers praised the helpfulness and friendliness of the staff, there were several reports of rudeness and unprofessional behavior from specific employees.
Customer Service
Customers expressed frustration with customer service issues, including long wait times, unhelpful responses, and complications with orders and promotions.
Store Cleanliness
The store is generally reported as clean and organized, although some customers noted areas that could use improvement.
Pricing Concerns
Several reviews mentioned that prices are considered high, and there were complaints about promotional offers not being honored.
Grooming Services
Grooming services received positive feedback for their care and attention to pets, although there were some negative experiences reported.
SS
Still-O
2 days ago
1.0
YESTERDAY I WENT IN TO PICK UP AN ORDER AND I SAW THROUGH THE WINDOW A WOMEN WAS GROOMING A DOG BETWEEN 11am-1pm IF ONE OF YOU TOOK TOUR DOG IN FOR GROOMING THAT TIME THE DOG WAS BEING MISTREATED. THE LADY WAS BEING AGGRESSIVE AND HITTING THE DOG.
ZC
Zaira Castillo
4 days ago
5.0
Ahora me tocó devolver mi ave lamentablemente ella no se adaptó en nuestra casa(picoteaba mucho a mi hija medio miedo cuando la atacó por el ojo ) !! Me dijeron que tenía que hablar con la Manager y ella muy amablemente me dijo que estaba bien y que esperaba que encontrara una cariñosa , cosa que me pareció excelente de parte de ella ya que eh visitado otros petcos y con la mentira que tienen que contar con la disque Manager nunca me resuelven nada porque nunca está ..
AL
apollo licata
5 days ago
2.0
Usually in life you can see a genuine person that shows empathy and love for a animal but the manager of this store had none of the above, when i tried to exchange cat food for somethinv else my cat can eat because she only had a few days of life left and had no teeth at 20 years young ,, but the manager flat out refused to exchange anything , well my precious girl passed away days ago and i still have the box of the food he wouldnt exchange , i will donate it to the pantry maybe it will help for anothee cat owner .
CG
Caeser Gaglio
Nov 14, 2025
1.0
No further discussions are necessary. My dog had a tag on his collar that showed he was vaccinated as I told the girl. This wasn’t good enough!! Very unprofessional, a waste of my time!!!!
VL
Veronica Liddle
Nov 13, 2025
1.0
I went to the bay shore location to get my two cats microchipped and the guy at the front told me the cats need to be in separate carriers. I told him i wasn’t aware that was a rule since I helped my dad few years ago to get his 2 cats microchipped at Petcos Syosset location in one carrier and the staff was fine with it. The guy did check me in and warned me that the staff might decline doing the service due to the carrier which I understand; however throughout the whole intake process he was still giving me an attitude about the whole carrier thing regarding the cats weight and I was getting irritated by it because i already told him I understand.
Then after that there were other patients arriving checking in and I saw a customer that was carrying his dog with no leash on it (only a collar) and the guy didn’t give him a problem about it at all. I was very offput by it since he was giving me a problem about the carrier, but not with the guy about the leash.
I search through my email to confirm the rules on carriers and leashes and found out that they both applied to cats and dogs under the quotes “dogs must be on leashes and cats must be in carriers.” However I find the carriers rule misleading since it’s can be read as a general thing and interpreted differently to people rather than specifying to have cats in separate carriers. But regardless it doesn’t give him the right to be nasty at someone who wasn’t aware of the rule vs enabling someone to not following the rules.
I will never come back and don’t recommend anyone to go.
Does the Petco Bay Shore location have a vet hospital?
Yes, Petco Bay Shore has a full-service vet hospital.
Does Petco Bay Shore offer vaccinations?
Yes, Petco Bay Shore provides vaccinations.
Does Petco Bay Shore offer curbside pickup?
Yes, curbside pickup is available at Petco Bay Shore. All of our products that are eligible for store pickup will show this option on the product's detail page.
How much are hamsters and guinea pigs at Bay Shore Petco?
Hamster and guinea pig prices vary by location. Call your Bay Shore Petco at 6312061047 to check for pricing and availabilty in your store. Or visit ourcompanion animal website for more information on small companion animals.
Does Petco Bay Shore sell dogs?
No, Bay Shore Petco does not sell dogs or cats. However, with the Petco Love program partnered with local animal welfare organizations, you have the opportunity to meet dogs and cats available for adoption at your neighborhood Petco store.
What veterinary services does Petco Bay Shore provide?
Petco Bay Shore has a full-service vet hospital and provides vaccinations for pets.
Does Petco Bay Shore offer curbside pickup and delivery options?
Yes, Petco Bay Shore offers curbside pickup and same day delivery services for eligible products.
What are the operating hours of Petco Bay Shore?
Petco Bay Shore is open Monday through Saturday from 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and Sunday from 9:00 AM to 8:00 PM.
Does Petco Bay Shore sell dogs or cats?
No, Petco Bay Shore does not sell dogs or cats. Instead, through the Petco Love program, customers can meet adoptable dogs and cats from local animal welfare organizations.
Where is Petco Bay Shore located?
Petco Bay Shore is located at 1851 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706.
How can I contact Petco Bay Shore?
You can contact Petco Bay Shore by calling +1 631-206-1047.
Does Petco Bay Shore have wheelchair accessible facilities?
Yes, Petco Bay Shore has a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, and restroom.
What nearby pet services are available around Petco Bay Shore?
Nearby pet services include Vetco Vaccination Clinic, Just Food For Dogs, Vetco Total Care Animal Hospital, and the VETCO Vaccination Clinic at PETCO, all convenient for comprehensive pet care.
What nearby shopping centers and stores can I visit around Petco Bay Shore?
Nearby shopping options include Market at Bay Shore, Five Below, Big Lots, The Home Depot, and Best Buy, allowing customers to combine their pet care visits with other shopping needs.
Are there any nearby places to eat or relax near Petco Bay Shore?
Nearby places to eat and relax include Buseto Pizza for Italian food and Sunrise Liquor Store for drinks; additionally, Lin's Nail Salon and Lins Nail Salon Spa offer beauty and spa services.