The Brenna Firm

Reviews

• SW

  Scott Weider

  Feb 24, 2026
  2.0
  Nearly 5 years after my cycling accident, the case against NYS is finally settled and closed. Opting for an arbitration settlement vs a trail was both frustrating and disappointing. While very impressed with the firm’s paralegal who clearly knows her stuff, (hence the reason for the 2 stars) my experience with counsel soured. I ultimately decided to settle through arbitration. Unfortunately I was unpleasantly surprised to learn, after the fact, there was one significant factor that would negatively impact the final settlement. A factor that was NEVER properly communicated to me by counsel, which counsel later denied (basically calling me a liar). Glad to be alive, case closed, time to move on….
• PC

  Pat Caldwell

  Nov 12, 2025
  1.0
  Walked into Sheldon's office at 9:58 this morning November 12,2025. Never met the man before but from his online profiles he seemed to be just what I was looking for. We introduced each other . He asked me what I was there for, I proceeded to tell him. He grabbed his phone and wrote down another attorneys number and handed it to me. I was back in my truck @ 10:05 . 7 mins and yes he charged me 500 dollars. I don't know how he sleeps at night.
• DP

  David Palermo

  Jun 10, 2019
  5.0
  I approached Mr. Brenna when I was unable to resolve a negligence case on my own. He expertly navigated the intricacies of the law and was able to garner the results I couldn’t and with a significantly better outcome. I’m grateful for partnering with him and his firm and, would have done so from the start of this had I known how valuable the relationship would prove itself to be.

Frequently Asked Questions About The Brenna Firm