Friendly - Reliable - Local. A friend you can rely on. For your car, home, business, and life Mathews Insurance, Inc. has it all for you at one of our two locations. From our offices in Athens, Ohio and McConnelsville, Ohio we serve the insurance needs of individuals, families, and businesses in Southeastern Ohio. As an independent insurance agency, we represent many top rated insurance companies. We're here for you locally, 24/7 via our website or by calling us at the location nearest you:
Mathews Insurance, Inc Athens, Ohio (740) 593-5573
James Insurance Agency McConnelsville, Ohio (740) 962-9900
We strive to provide you with the right insurance protection, superior claim service when you need it and the essential convenience of a local office. Mathews Insurance, Inc. is proud to serve you!
Details
Requires appointmentNot available
Wheelchair accessible entranceAvailable
Location
Certified by Mathews Insurance, Inc • Jul 05, 2026
Knowing your home is covered can take a lot of stress off ones shoulders. A homeowner policy reimburses you for damage to your home from a variety of causes. If your home is totally destroyed or you cannot use it for a period of time, your homeowner policy will also cover that. The insurance extends to your home's contents and liability for damage to property of others or injury caused to someone by you or a family member. Your policy can be personalized to include greater levels of protection for important property, home office situations, liability for boat ownership and additions and alterations to your residence.
Mathews Insurance, Inc. represents several top rated car insurance companies so we can help you sort through your options and get you multiple auto insurance quotes, all right here in one place.
Some car insurance discounts available to you:
•Deductible
•Safe Driver
•Safety Equipment
•Homeowner Credit
•Safety Features
Contact an Ohio car insurance agent today at Mathews Insurance, Inc. to get free comparative quote.
Boat owners and enthusiasts in the state of Ohio are a broad group, plying the waters with a variety of watercraft. We can tailor the right insurance for a range of 'boats' such as:
•Jet skis
•Power boats of all varieties
•Sailboats
•Yachts
•Trailers
•Related Equipment
As an independent insurance agent in Ohio, Mathews Insurance, Inc. has access to numerous, top rated boat insurance companies, so you can take advantage of reviewing several competitive boat insurance quotes all in one place.
What is condo insurance? Condo Insurance covers your property from the outside walls in, your property both at and sometimes away from your condominium, and provides you with liability insurance as well.
Protect the possessions in your condo and a whole lot more
Very similar to a homeowner policy, a condo owners' insurance policy can be customized in a variety of ways depending on your needs. You aren't required to carry insurance for common areas or the outside of the building, but your condo owners' association may have special requirements, so it's a good idea to review those with your Mathews Insurance agent.
Dwelling Fire Insurance is designed to insure residences you own or have a financial interest in but do not live in. Common situations calling for this type of insurance coverage include investment properties (rental homes), homes that are vacant because they are temporarily uninhabitable or are not currently occupied because of a transition caused by a sale or relocation. In these situations insurance protection is needed for the building but typically not for any contents. Liability insurance for the property can usually be added or may be handled through alternative approaches.
This inexpensive policy can do a lot for you! If you rent a home, apartment or even a townhouse, why wouldn't you want to insure your personal property? A renters insurance policy will cover your personal property as well as provide coverage for loss of use and your personal liability. While you're at it, ask for an auto quote! Many companies offer a package discount when you write your renters insurance and auto insurance with the same company.
A Business Owners Policy for your business, sometimes called a BOP, provides several important insurance protections for: buildings, personal business property, business interruption, bodily injury liability and property damage liability. These policies are designed especially for small and medium sized businesses, and can be customized to fit the needs of a wide variety of commercial enterprises.
Convenient options for insuring small and medium businesses in Ohio
Let a business insurance agent here at Mathews Insurance, Inc. review your needs and provide you with several competitive premium comparisons. Getting the right policy with the right coverage limits is crucial to safeguarding your business from losses that could result in disaster. Contact one of the Business Owners Policy professionals at Mathews Insurance, Inc. for a no obligation insurance quote.
A Commercial Package is a type of business package policy that bundles coverage together for several things including liability, property, boiler and machinery, crime and other optional coverage. The options available create flexibility that allow a Package to be customized for most kinds of business.
Commercial General Liability Insurance is an essential business coverage that protects you and your business from claims and lawsuits against you in that might occur in the course of operating your business. Identifying potential business liability risks is something
Mathews Insurance, Inc. has a lot of experience with, and we represent several commercial insurance companies, so we can provide you a range of options. Contacting a Business Insurance Professional at Mathews Insurance, Inc. is a step in the right direction when it comes determining your exposure to Commercial General Liability claims as well as establishing appropriate limits.
Standard commercial insurance liability limits should be enough to protect your business from most situations where your business is charged with legal liability for injury or property damage. But it won't cover those catastrophic lawsuits and judgments that are increasing in frequency. Commercial umbrella insurance provides an affordable layer of excess liability insurance for your business above the limits provided by standard business liability policies and could mean the difference between staying in business or becoming a lawsuit casualty in situations like this:
•A company employee causes an accident that results in a permanent disability to the driver of the other vehicle.
•A product you distribute is found to be defective and the cause of illness to multiple people.
•An employee becomes intoxicated during a business dinner, causes an auto accident and injures a passenger, who is a prospective client.
Excess Business Liability Insurance is Essential
There are literally dozens and dozens of situations where liability claims can exceed your commercial or professional liability insurance coverage limits. A commercial liability insurance agent at Mathews Insurance, Inc. can help you identify and control those exposures and review coverage options from several top rated insurance companies. Contact us today to get the right protection for your business.
Farm and ranch insurance can be tailored to protect the part-time gentleman farmer to the full scale agribusiness. Plans can include protection for your personal and business assets and legal liability insurance for both personal and farming pursuits. To get a proposal suited to your individual needs, complete our Farm Quote Request form or use the contact link below. And of course, you can always call or stop by to learn more.
You can visit our website to view the multiple Group or Individual options available.
Reviews
4.8
35 reviews
5 stars
30
4 stars
3
3 stars
2
2 stars0
1 star0
KS
Kelly Shaw
Apr 16, 2026
5.0
Mathews Insurance and Mallory Swain were exceptionally helpful in determining specific coverage for our local non-profit organization. Having a policy quote that addresses our unique needs, with friendly and responsive communication to all our questions was so appreciated.
TD
Tyler Dunham
Feb 9, 2026
5.0
My agent Mallory was very wonderful for the years I had Mathews Insurance and was always only a phone call or text away! It was a great place to have my first insurance plan through as when I had my first claim she was there to help me through the whole process.
CC
Courtney
Feb 3, 2026
5.0
The entire staff at Mathews Insurance has been amazing to deal with. My family has used them for many years and have been nothing but 100% satisfied. They are quick to answer any questions and go up and beyond when you may need guidance or help. Mallory, Brooke and the rest of the office staff are professional and go beyond what is expected...they are truly a joy to work with.
LH
Lindsey Hamlin
Oct 31, 2021
5.0
Top notch!
DR
Dr. Jessie Rose
May 21, 2020
5.0
Every interaction with Mathews Insurance has been a pleasure. I'm especially grateful to my agent, Mallory Swaim, who has helped me secure the best value on home owners, flood, and auto insurance. More than once, she has taken the initiative to save me money and time. She's a treasure who makes "dealing with insurance" feel good!
Frequently Asked Questions About Mathews Insurance, Inc
What types of insurance does Mathews Insurance, Inc provide?
Mathews Insurance, Inc offers insurance for cars, homes, businesses, life, renters, boats, and motorcycles.
Where is Mathews Insurance, Inc located?
Mathews Insurance, Inc is located at 240 Columbus Rd, Athens, OH 45701, United States.
What are the regular business hours for Mathews Insurance, Inc in Athens?
The office is open Monday to Thursday from 7:30 AM to 4:30 PM and Friday from 7:30 AM to 4:00 PM. It is closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
Is it necessary to make an appointment to visit Mathews Insurance, Inc?
No, appointments are not required, but they also offer services by appointment if preferred.
Is Mathews Insurance, Inc wheelchair accessible?
Yes, Mathews Insurance, Inc has wheelchair accessible entrances and parking available.
How can I contact Mathews Insurance, Inc for insurance needs?
You can call them at (740) 593-5573 or visit their website at http://www.MathewsInsurance.com.
Which nearby automotive services can I visit along with Mathews Insurance, Inc?
Nearby automotive services include Hugh White Honda Athens, Jeep dealership, Hugh White Nissan Athens, and Muffler Man for repairs and parts.
Are there gas stations near Mathews Insurance, Inc for convenience?
Yes, BP and Valero / City Limits gas stations are nearby, useful if you need fuel before or after visiting Mathews Insurance.
What community services are close to Mathews Insurance, Inc?
Nearby community services include Health Recovery Services, Building Bridges Adult Center, and Southeastern Ohio Teen Institute, which offer health and social support.
Does Mathews Insurance, Inc serve businesses as well as individuals?
Yes, they serve insurance needs of individuals, families, and businesses in Southeastern Ohio with multiple top-rated insurance companies.
Brand Certified Facts from Mathews Insurance, Inc
This information is certified by Mathews Insurance, Inc and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified July 05, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: