Matthew Devine: Allstate Insurance

Reviews

• MV

  Mary Vandervoet

  May 6, 2026
  3.0
  Price keeps going up and we haven’t gotten a ticket, had no accidents, we are 61 and seems the older we get the prices go up!
• LS

  Lindsey Senften

  May 6, 2026
  5.0
  Great Agents and the Service team is AMAZING!!
• EM

  eric medel

  Apr 25, 2026
  5.0
  Blair Barnhill is great she did a great a job had to go out my way to let everyone know!
• SM

  Stacy Mead

  Apr 8, 2026
  1.0
  This has been one of the most incompetent and unacceptable experiences I’ve ever had with a company. The level of customer service at the Matthew Devine Agency is so poor that it feels borderline fraudulent. They incorrectly applied a payment to my account and then refused to correct their mistake. My mortgage company and I have provided clear documentation showing that the correct amount was paid. Because of their error, they wrongfully cancelled my homeowner’s insurance, leaving me scrambling to fix a problem they created. This is not just careless, it’s completely irresponsible. Even now, I have not received a refund, nor have they made any real effort to reinstate my policy. Getting a straight answer or any accountability has been nearly impossible. I would strongly advise others to steer clear of the Matthew Devine Agency.
• BJ

  Billie Jetter

  Mar 20, 2026
  1.0
  Using alstate insurance was the worse experience I have ever had with a insurance company!