Business Details
About
Insurance AgencyAuto Insurance AgencyBusiness Insurance Service
Kalsey Insurance Agency is your trusted independent insurance agent in Waynesburg, PA. We are proud to serve all of Pennsylvania and Northern West Virginia with comprehensive insurance coverage for home, auto, commercial, farm, renters, and recreational vehicles since 1970.
As a locally owned independent insurance agency, we work with multiple insurance carriers to find the best coverage at the most competitive rates. Our experience allows us to take the time to understand your unique insurance needs and tailor a policy that provides you with the protection you need.
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.8
316 reviews
5 stars
287
4 stars
16
3 stars3
2 stars
5
1 star
5
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Customer Service
Customers consistently praised the friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable staff, highlighting their willingness to assist and explain processes.
Efficiency
Many reviews noted the quick and efficient service, particularly for title transfers and notary services, making the experience smooth and hassle-free.
Affordability
The business is recognized for its reasonable pricing and competitive rates for insurance and title services.
Professionalism
Overall, the staff demonstrated professionalism and competence, with several customers mentioning their expertise in handling various services.
Community Focus
As a local family-run business, Kalsey Insurance has built a loyal customer base, with many long-term clients expressing satisfaction with the personal touch and community involvement.
- LLLisa3 days ago5.0Recommend Kalsey’s 100%. My whole families go to for all of our insurance needs, title work, notary, etc… Always there to answer any question we may have and help with any issues. HEATHER is our go to lady, she has been our favorite for several years, she definitely knows her job and is very kind, always smiling and very helpful with everything! That’s a rare find at most companies!
- EPemily peel4 days ago5.0We recently moved back to the area and everyone at Kalsey Insurance Agency has been so helpful guiding us through transferring everything from Illinois to PA. Their expertise is top notch! Shout out to Grace for her knowledge and diligence with our title work. She’s the best!
- MDMarcia Davis4 days ago5.0Kalsey Insurance has been absolutely wonderful to work with! From the moment I reached out, their team was friendly, patient, and truly focused on helping me find the best coverage for my needs. They took the time to explain my options clearly and made the entire process feel easy and stress-free. What really stands out is their genuine care for their customers. They respond quickly, follow through on every detail, and make you feel like a priority—not just another policy. It’s rare to find that level of personal service these days. If you’re looking for reliable, knowledgeable, and personable insurance agents, I highly recommend Kalsey Insurance. They’ve earned my trust, and I’m grateful for the excellent service they provide!
- KRKristin Rudy4 days ago5.0Kalsey Insurance is a family owned company across multiple generations. It is managed by dedicated employees who are willing to adapt and see insurance plan needs for each family and individual. Located in the Waynesburg area, it is heart of the community and one for the community! I trust the services provided at Kalsey Insurance and so should you !
- WGwilliam grim5 days ago5.0Use them for all my car title transfers an rental insurance, Heather Moore Orndoff is absolutely the best! Always more then willing to help me with every single question I have about anything they offer there. Goes outta her way for sure even if im asking her a question on fb even after hours some times. Highly recommend using them!!!!
Frequently Asked Questions About Kalsey Insurance Agency
What types of insurance coverage does Kalsey Insurance Agency offer?
Kalsey Insurance Agency offers insurance coverage for home, auto, commercial, farm, renters, and recreational vehicles.
Where is Kalsey Insurance Agency located?
Kalsey Insurance Agency is located at 238 West High Street, Waynesburg, PA 15370, US.
What are the business hours of Kalsey Insurance Agency?
The agency is open Monday through Thursday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM, Friday from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM, and Saturday from 9:00 AM to 12:00 PM. It is closed on Sunday.
How can I contact Kalsey Insurance Agency?
You can contact them by phone at +1 724-627-3147 or email at ross@kalseyinsurance.com.
Does Kalsey Insurance Agency accept credit cards and other payment methods?
Yes, they accept American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, Financing options, MasterCard, and Visa.
Is Kalsey Insurance Agency independently owned and how does that benefit customers?
Yes, it is a locally owned independent agency, which allows them to work with multiple insurance carriers to find the best coverage at the most competitive rates tailored to your unique needs.
Can you recommend nearby places a customer might visit before or after an appointment at Kalsey Insurance Agency?
Nearby places include The Way Community Center for community events and Moschetta's Performing Arts Center for theatre shows.
Where can customers find automotive or truck rental services close to Kalsey Insurance Agency?
U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer, offering truck rentals and automotive services, is conveniently located near Kalsey Insurance Agency.
What local dining options are available near Kalsey Insurance Agency?
College Town Diner and Don Patron Waynesburg, a Tex-Mex and Mexican restaurant, are nearby dining choices for customers.
Are there any local health and wellness services near Kalsey Insurance Agency?
Yes, nearby wellness services include Opalescence Hair Company for beauty and spa needs, The Hidden Spa for massage therapy, and various counseling services such as RLD Counseling, LLC.