Brand Certified
The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More…
5.0(758 reviews)
Certified by The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More… • Mar 01, 2026
Business Details
424 W Plane Street, Bethel, OH
45106, United States
Certified by The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More… • Mar 01, 2026
(513) 466-0209
Certified by The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More… • Mar 01, 2026
http://medicare.moderninsurancestore.com
Certified by The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More… • Mar 01, 2026
About
Certified by The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More… • Mar 01, 2026
Insurance BrokerLife Insurance AgencyHealth Insurance Agency
We help individuals, families, and small businesses with Health insurance, Life Insurance, Medicare supplements, Medicare Advantage, Medicare Part D Prescription plans, Dental Insurance, Vision Insurance, Annuities, and more...
Location
Certified by The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More… • Mar 01, 2026
The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More…
424 W Plane Street, Bethel, OH
45106, United States
Hours
Certified by The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More… • Mar 01, 2026
Reviews
5.0
758 reviews
5 stars
736
4 stars
18
3 stars2
2 stars0
1 star2
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Agent Knowledge
Customers consistently praised the agents for their extensive knowledge and ability to explain complex insurance options clearly.
Customer Service
Many reviews highlighted the agents' patience, kindness, and willingness to help, making clients feel comfortable throughout the process.
Overall Experience
The majority of customers reported a positive experience, expressing gratitude for the assistance received and recommending the service to others.
Communication Issues
A few customers experienced communication breakdowns, with missed calls and rescheduling issues noted as areas for improvement.
- BSBelinda Simpson3 days ago5.0Jayson was very helpful and went over all my information very thoroughly.
- AMAlden McKayFeb 12, 20265.0Jayden was incredibly helpful and pleasant. I’m grateful for his help!
- NMnya mosesFeb 9, 20265.0Great, Insurance representative I was really confused didn’t know my options or what plan to choose Jayden clearly explained to me what I wanted to know about Medicare , I am very thankful!
- CWCatherine WheatFeb 3, 20265.0I am very pleased with Jaydon, he helped me with the insurance that was right for me and he checks in to make sure I'm getting exactly what I need.
- DADavid AndersonJan 14, 20265.0Medicare Advantage programs confusing, complex, and frightening? Call the Modern Insurance Store for professional, thorough and guidance through this annual event. We had Harlan as an agent and counselor. He went through various providers, pros and cons until we felt comfortable with our choice and the options we needed for this year. One of the most comfortable we have felt with an agent of any description. If there were 10 stars for rating our experience, we would have chosen and rated them that. Thanks to Harlan again for helping us with our decision!
Frequently Asked Questions About The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More…
What types of insurance does The Modern Insurance Store offer?
They offer Health insurance, Life Insurance, Medicare supplements, Medicare Advantage, Medicare Part D Prescription plans, Dental Insurance, Vision Insurance, Annuities, and more.
In which states does The Modern Insurance Store provide service?
They serve many regions including Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, Missouri, Wisconsin, Florida, Tennessee, Arkansas, West Virginia, Arizona, Texas, Oklahoma, Kansas, Nebraska, Iowa, New Mexico, Alabama, Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Virginia.
What are the business hours for The Modern Insurance Store?
Monday to Friday, they are open from 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM, and on Saturday from 9:00 AM to 12:00 PM. They are closed on Sundays.
How can I contact The Modern Insurance Store?
You can contact them via phone at +1 513-467-4209 (main phone), +1 513-427-4221 (local phone), or toll free at +1 866-572-9255. You can also email them at info@moderninsurancestore.com.
Where is The Modern Insurance Store located?
Their address is 424 W Plane Street, Bethel, OH 45106, USA.
Where can I find more information or book an appointment with The Modern Insurance Store online?
You can visit their website at https://moderninsurancestore.com or use their contact page at https://moderninsurancestore.com/contact to get in touch or make reservations.
What are some nearby places I can visit around The Modern Insurance Store?
Nearby you can find Community Savings Bank for your banking needs, The Shepherd's Place for community services, Bishop's Hardware for building supplies, and several churches like Bethel United Methodist Church and Living The Word Church for worship.
Are there any food options close to The Modern Insurance Store?
Yes, nearby you can grab a meal at Subway, Blue Haven Restaurant, or visit Redbox for some entertainment rentals.
Where can I find nearby postal and shipping services when visiting The Modern Insurance Store?
There is a UPS Access Point location and UPS Authorized Shipping Provider close by for your courier and delivery service needs.
Are there any nearby places to take care of children while visiting The Modern Insurance Store?
Happy Days Nursery School and Big Bear Child Care are nearby day care and preschool options in the area.
Brand Certified Facts from The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More…
The Modern Insurance Store - Medicare, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and More… partners directly with Yext to publish this data from the brand's official system of record. Learn more about our data sources
Certified March 01, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website