Brand Certified
First Choice Insurance
4.5(54 reviews)
Certified by First Choice Insurance • Mar 08, 2026
Business Details
646 Wellwood Avenue, Lindenhurst, NY
11757, United States
Certified by First Choice Insurance • Mar 08, 2026
(631) 422-6650
Certified by First Choice Insurance • Mar 08, 2026
https://www.firstchoiceins.com/
Certified by First Choice Insurance • Mar 08, 2026
About
Certified by First Choice Insurance • Mar 08, 2026
Insurance AgencyInsurance BrokerInsurance ConsultantHome Insurance AgencyProperty Insurance AgencyBusiness Insurance ServiceAuto Insurance Agency
Since 1987, First Choice Insurance Agency, Inc. has been providing clients in the NYC area with world-class insurance service and products. Our clients are so satisfied with our service that over 70% of our new clients are referred to us by them!
Affordable Auto Insurance, Affordable Business Insurance, Affordable Car Insurance, Auto Insurance, Builders Risk Insurance, Business Insurance, Car Insurance, Cheap Auto Insurance, Cheap Business Insurance, Cheapest Car Insurance, Commercial Insurance, Contractors Insurance, Flood Insurance, General Liability Insurance, Health Insurance, Home Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Insurance, Medical Insurance, Small Business Insurance, Tool and Equipment Insurance, CGL Insurance
Location
Certified by First Choice Insurance • Mar 08, 2026
Hours
Certified by First Choice Insurance • Mar 08, 2026
Reviews
4.5
54 reviews
5 stars
45
4 stars
2
3 stars
1
2 stars
1
1 star
5
- JFj flo4 days ago5.0Great service with kelly she was very helpful and friendly. I would advise to come here for all insurance purposes they get things done, 5 star service.
- RRruthMar 3, 20265.0definitely feel at home with first choice insurance agency. the staff is helpful and informative and always goes above and beyond to ensure i'm paying the best price!
- ALAj LeddyFeb 6, 20265.0Had a wonderful experience working with Kelly. She was very competent and quick to answer any questions I had. I would definitely recommend Kelly from first choice insurance for an amazing and seamless process!
- SOSubair ObaidiJan 28, 20261.0They were taking my payments every month they didn’t tell me that my insurance had closed 2 months ago. They tried blaming everyone except themselves for the mistake. Ended up paying 1200$ more for a new policy. Big red flag I would never recommend anyone to go here. P.s. this isn’t a bogus review. Who would take a time out their day to review this and create a fake story. Unethical business at its finest.
- RARemyi Almonte-FernandezDec 18, 20251.0Terrible service
Frequently Asked Questions About First Choice Insurance
What types of insurance does First Choice Insurance offer?
First Choice Insurance offers Homeowner's Insurance, Flood Insurance, Auto Insurance, Business Insurance, and Commercial Insurance.
Where is First Choice Insurance located?
First Choice Insurance is located at 646 Wellwood Avenue, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, USA.
What are the business hours for First Choice Insurance?
First Choice Insurance is open Monday, Wednesday, and Friday from 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM; Tuesday and Thursday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM; and Saturday from 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM. It is closed on Sunday.
How can I contact First Choice Insurance?
You can contact First Choice Insurance by phone at +1 631-422-6650 or via email at info@firstchoiceins.com.
Does First Choice Insurance have an online presence?
Yes, you can visit their website at https://www.firstchoiceins.com/ and follow them on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/FirstChoiceAgency/ or on Twitter @FirstChoiceins2.
Since when has First Choice Insurance been serving clients?
First Choice Insurance has been serving clients since 1987.
Are there any places nearby where I can relax or dine after visiting First Choice Insurance?
Yes, nearby you can visit Outback Steakhouse, a popular American restaurant and steakhouse, for dining after your appointment.
What nearby facilities can support my health and wellness around First Choice Insurance?
Near First Choice Insurance, you can find Louis Lasky Memorial Medical (a dentist), Magic Smiles For Kids (pediatric dentist), CityMD (emergency room and medical center), and Dr Jay Riess Chiropractor for various health services.
Are there any convenient stores close to First Choice Insurance for quick shopping?
Yes, Dollar General, a discount store offering arts and crafts supplies, and Sunrise Farm Market, a grocery store and farmers market, are close by for your shopping convenience.
Can I find nearby services for personal care and beauty around First Choice Insurance?
Yes, nearby personal care options include Angel Tips Nail Salon, Esther's Nail & Spa, Sebastiano Unisex Salon, and Perfect Color Tanning Salon for beauty and spa services.
Brand Certified Facts from First Choice Insurance
This information is certified by First Choice Insurance and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified March 08, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website