I am an Allstate agent for over 23 years in this town and a member of the Huntington Chamber of Commerce. I have sponsored many local sports teams and have contributed to many local charitable organizations!
David is amazing and a true Professional
I am fortunate to find him
RR
Ralph
Nov 19, 2025
1.0
After 25 years with the Allstate Tuohy Agency and David Tuohy personally handling our home and auto insurance, we were incredibly disappointed with how we were treated. We never filed a single claim in all those years. Then, after two related water-damage claims, we were suddenly dropped—with no warning, no conversation, and no attempt at customer service.
What made it worse was that David wouldn’t even return our phone calls. After decades of loyalty (and clear overpayment because we believed we had a long-standing, trusted relationship), we expected at least honesty and communication. Instead, we were ignored the moment we needed help.
If you’re looking for an agent who values long-term customers, communicates, or stands by you when something goes wrong, I would strongly recommend looking elsewhere. This experience was extremely disappointing and showed us exactly how little our loyalty meant.
MM
Monique M
Nov 19, 2023
5.0
Easy and outstanding service
AN
Arlene Northcote
Jul 27, 2023
5.0
Easy company to navigate. Questions / concerns promptly answered. Allstate does what’s best for their clients.
RG
Richard R Gomes
May 6, 2023
5.0
Other than some minor telephone tag, my experience with this agency is always top notch
Frequently Asked Questions About David Tuohy Jr.: Allstate Insurance
What is the address of David Tuohy Jr.: Allstate Insurance?
The office is located at 202 E Main St, Ste 107, Huntington, NY 11743, USA.
What are the business hours of this Allstate Insurance agent?
The office is open Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM and closed on weekends.
How many years has David Tuohy Jr. been an Allstate agent in Huntington?
David Tuohy Jr. has been an Allstate agent in Huntington for over 23 years.
What types of insurance does David Tuohy Jr.: Allstate Insurance specialize in?
They specialize in commercial insurance, boat insurance, flood insurance, auto insurance, homeowners insurance, life insurance, renters insurance, and more.
Does David Tuohy Jr.: Allstate Insurance offer online appointment scheduling?
Yes, online appointments are offered through their reservation page.
What is the main contact number and email for David Tuohy Jr.: Allstate Insurance?
You can contact them by phone at +1 631-423-1200 or by email at DavidTuohyJr@allstate.com.
Are there any nearby medical services or doctors close to the insurance office?
Yes, nearby medical services include Ramos Periodontics, Lawrence Horn (Obstetrician and Gynecologist), north shore Headache and Spine, Irene R Siegel PhD (Psychologist), and North Shore Medical Wellness.
What food and beverage spots are near David Tuohy Jr.'s office?
Nearby food and beverage places include Baskin-Robbins ice cream shop, Dunkin' coffee shop, Foodworx delicatessen, OM Organics Grab and Go cafe, and Duck Island Bread Company Artisan Bakery.
Are there any wellness or spa services near the Allstate office?
Yes, nearby wellness and spa services include Vanessa M. Meyer LLC (naturopathic holistic), The Wellness Room, and Natural Care Chiropractic offering massage therapy and acupuncture.
How can customers visiting David Tuohy Jr.: Allstate Insurance benefit from the nearby businesses?
Customers can conveniently access nearby health professionals, wellness centers, food options, and other local services in Huntington, making it easy to combine insurance needs with other errands or appointments.