David Tuohy Jr.: Allstate Insurance

Reviews

• SS

  Stephen Strauss

  Dec 26, 2025
  5.0
  David is amazing and a true Professional I am fortunate to find him
• RR

  Ralph

  Nov 19, 2025
  1.0
  After 25 years with the Allstate Tuohy Agency and David Tuohy personally handling our home and auto insurance, we were incredibly disappointed with how we were treated. We never filed a single claim in all those years. Then, after two related water-damage claims, we were suddenly dropped—with no warning, no conversation, and no attempt at customer service. What made it worse was that David wouldn’t even return our phone calls. After decades of loyalty (and clear overpayment because we believed we had a long-standing, trusted relationship), we expected at least honesty and communication. Instead, we were ignored the moment we needed help. If you’re looking for an agent who values long-term customers, communicates, or stands by you when something goes wrong, I would strongly recommend looking elsewhere. This experience was extremely disappointing and showed us exactly how little our loyalty meant.
• AN

  Arlene Northcote

  Jul 27, 2023
  5.0
  Easy company to navigate. Questions / concerns promptly answered. Allstate does what’s best for their clients.
• RP

  Roy Pisano

  Jul 19, 2023
  5.0
  Very nice people working there. David is very knowledgeable and helpful when you are setting up or changing your policy
• RG

  Richard R Gomes

  May 6, 2023
  5.0
  Other than some minor telephone tag, my experience with this agency is always top notch