Here at the Weatherly Insurance Agency, we put our Client’s needs first. We have been serving the needs of Clients in Eastern North Carolina and the Outer Banks since 1984. Our dedicated team of Licensed Agents specialize in finding the best personalized Insurance solutions – including home insurance, auto insurance and business insurance – at the best rates. With 6 locations in Kill Devil Hills, Greenville, Columbia, Elizabeth City, Edenton and Mt. Olive, we are insuring what you’ve worked so hard for by ensuring we work hard for you.
Very good she save me a lot of money with a different insurance company.
JS
Janet Stone
Dec 11, 2025
5.0
Kristi Neal is amazing! She made insurance easy to understand and kept me updated by text so I didn’t miss anything. She’s patient, kind, super responsive—and she even helped cut my payment in half. Highly recommend!
KJ
Kathy Jorgensen
Dec 1, 2025
5.0
Their team was very reassuring and there when they were needed!
JB
John Barlow
Nov 24, 2025
5.0
My Wife and I had another known insurance agency in the OBX for 15 years, Their customer service was atrocious - you'd rarely. if at all get a return phone call on any questions we may have had with our auto. Homeowners or wind & gale policies. We switched the 3 policies last summer to Weatherly. Professional. pleasant & knowledgeable staff who have serviced us better in 6 months than the other did in 15 years.
LC
Louise Carr
Nov 24, 2025
5.0
All of my experiences with Weatherly have been great. All issues are answered promptly. Great customer service.
Frequently Asked Questions About Weatherly Insurance Agency, Inc.
Where is Weatherly Insurance Agency, Inc. located?
Weatherly Insurance Agency, Inc. is located at 2810 North Croatan Highway, Kill Devil Hills, NC 27948, USA.
What types of insurance does Weatherly Insurance Agency provide?
They specialize in home insurance, auto insurance, business insurance, property insurance, and renter's insurance.
What are the business hours for Weatherly Insurance Agency, Inc.?
They are open Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM, and closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
How many locations does Weatherly Insurance Agency have?
Weatherly Insurance Agency has 6 locations serving Eastern North Carolina and the Outer Banks, including Kill Devil Hills, Greenville, Columbia, Elizabeth City, Edenton, and Mt. Olive.
What payment methods are accepted by Weatherly Insurance Agency?
They accept cash, check, Mastercard, and Visa for payments.
How can I contact Weatherly Insurance Agency via phone or email?
You can reach them by phone at +1 252-480-1284 or +1 888-689-2429, or by email at jamie@weatherlyinsurance.com.
Does Weatherly Insurance Agency offer services in languages other than English?
Currently, they provide services in English.
What nearby services can I find close to Weatherly Insurance Agency in Kill Devil Hills?
Nearby, you can access Nationwide Insurance agencies, PPG Paint Store, Wells Fargo Bank, and Complete Business Services among others, which provide complementary services such as insurance, hardware supplies, banking, and printing.
Are there any wellness or recreational facilities near Weatherly Insurance Agency?
Yes, Drift Away Massage OBX, Seaside Wellness spa, First Flight Lions Club gym, and Lions Club Bingo entertainment venue are all nearby for relaxation and recreation.
What attractions or other useful services are available near Weatherly Insurance Agency?
You can visit Jake Rogers Gallery for art, Outer Banks FOE 4506 Eagle Riders Club for community events, and nearby automotive dealers like Outer Banks Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram and Island Jeep and Car Rentals for vehicle needs.