Metzger Insurance Agency is a trusted insurance broker in Benton Harbor, MI and St. Joseph, MI, committed to providing affordable and quality coverage tailored to your needs. Our experienced team specializes in life insurance coverage in Benton Harbor, MI and St. Joseph, MI, helping individuals and families secure their financial future with reliable policies. We also offer auto insurance coverage in Benton Harbor, MI and St. Joseph, MI, ensuring drivers receive comprehensive protection at competitive rates. Whether you're seeking personal or business insurance, our knowledgeable agents are ready to guide you through the process with clarity and expertise. Contact us today for a consultation.
Very unhappy with Metzgers my home insurance in 2022 was about $600 just three years ago and now has doubled to over $1200 but my home has not doubled in price. I have a brick ranch style home with a fire hydrant right on my property. I haven’t had time to call them but I am very unhappy and don’t want to pay for peoples property in hurricane and tornado ravaged areas this is ridiculous!
TC
The Cajun Chef
Sep 28, 2025
5.0
Very helpful and easy to work with.
VV
VioletLisa
Nov 13, 2024
5.0
I Love This Insurance Company! It has the nicest people and the best prices I've ever seen anyways! I wouldn't change company's for anything. 😁
SF
shannon felgner
Sep 26, 2024
1.0
A lot of interactions adding up to one star. Sorry, I would not choose Metzger. :(
Frequently Asked Questions About Metzger Insurance Agency
What services does Metzger Insurance Agency offer?
Metzger Insurance Agency provides life and auto insurance coverage for individuals and businesses in Benton Harbor, MI and St. Joseph, MI, offering affordable and quality coverage tailored to your needs.
Where is Metzger Insurance Agency located?
The agency is located at 4146 Michigan 139, St. Joseph, MI 49085, USA.
What are the office hours for Metzger Insurance Agency?
The agency is open Monday through Friday from 8:00 AM to 12:00 PM and 1:00 PM to 5:00 PM. It is closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
How can I contact Metzger Insurance Agency?
You can reach Metzger Insurance Agency by phone at +1 269-429-3160 or via email at metzgerins@comcast.net.
Does Metzger Insurance Agency have an online presence?
Yes, you can visit their website at http://www.metzgerinsurance.net for more information and to contact them.
What types of insurance does Metzger Insurance Agency specialize in?
They specialize in life and auto insurance coverage, helping individuals and families secure financial protection with reliable policies.
Is there a good place to eat near Metzger Insurance Agency?
Yes, El Sol Azteca, a Tex-Mex restaurant, and Joe’s Cafe Breakfast House, an American breakfast spot, are nearby options for dining before or after your visit.
Where can I find gas stations near Metzger Insurance Agency?
Nearby gas stations include Pri Mart Quik Shop, Amoco, and bp America, convenient for refueling or quick stops when visiting the agency.
Are there any wellness or fitness centers close to Metzger Insurance Agency?
Yes, the Relief Chiropractic and Wellness Center and Tempest Yoga studio are nearby, perfect for a wellness session before or after handling your insurance needs.
Can I visit other local businesses near Metzger Insurance Agency for home or construction needs?
Nearby businesses like Village Lamp Shoppe, OBM Construction and Custom Homes LLC, and Pater True Value provide lighting, construction, and paint supplies to support your home projects.