Newman & Tucker Insurance

Reviews

• DV

  Dino Vlahakis

  Feb 24, 2026
  5.0
  Working with Brooks Benson for Newman and Tucker Insurance. I had an excellent experience working with this insurance company for my business coverage. The process was smooth, straightforward, and handled very efficiently. Their team was responsive, knowledgeable, and took the time to explain everything clearly. On top of that, the pricing was very competitive and offered great value for the coverage provided. I highly recommend them to any business owner looking for reliable and affordable insurance. Dino Vlahakis Pickwick Theatre Inc
• JB

  Jena Bordeaux

  Feb 23, 2026
  5.0
  I worked with Rachel. She was amazing! And even worked out an almost impossible deadline!
• DD

  dev deque

  Dec 27, 2025
  1.0
  I was with them for two decades. From 16 till just a few months ago. I don't recommend them. I never got a courtesy call or email once. They never asked if I was happy or tried to save me a buck. Never contacted when the insurance company made mistakes or overcharged me. I recently got a newer vehicle. They had me paying $175/m for full coverage. Complained and they came back at $120/m... The agent wasn't helpful at all. They wouldn't take or return my calls for days. So I went elsewhere and got the same coverage for only $65/m - with a more modern insurance company. Over the years, there were issues where I had strong feelings of being taken advantage of. I don't know why anyone would need Newman and Tucker. I shouldn't have been so hesitant to shop around for a different agency. I assumed they had my back for being a customer for so long. Boy was I wrong! Edit: Maybe just me. But their response only proves how bad they are. Steer clear. They are NOT the only option in the area. 👎
• SR

  Sean Redding

  Oct 5, 2025
  5.0
  Helped me to get the best price for a great value for my home and auto insurance, and continued to follow up to insure that I was reimbursed for unused months when I had to switch to a company with international coverage. You expect good service when you arrive, but you don't always get it when you depart. Newman and Tucker delivered on both fronts, and for that we were thankful.

Frequently Asked Questions About Newman & Tucker Insurance