Brand Certified
1st Choice Insurance Services
4.9(36 reviews)
Certified by 1st Choice Insurance Services • Apr 05, 2026
Business Details
4975 W State Road 10, North Judson, IN
46366, United States
Certified by 1st Choice Insurance Services • Apr 05, 2026
(574) 896-3482
Certified by 1st Choice Insurance Services • Apr 05, 2026
https://www.1stchoiceinsurance.net/
Certified by 1st Choice Insurance Services • Apr 05, 2026
About
Certified by 1st Choice Insurance Services • Apr 05, 2026
Auto Insurance AgencyHome Insurance AgencyInsurance AgencyInsurance Consultant
1st Choice Insurance Services has proudly served Starke County since 1897, providing trusted insurance solutions to families, businesses, and individuals in our community. Over the years, we’ve grown to meet the needs of our customers, and in 2024, we expanded to a second location in Knox, while continuing to serve from our flagship office in North Judson, Indiana.
We offer a full range of coverage, including auto, homeowners, commercial, life, health, and group insurance, with a focus on personalized service and expert guidance. Our team is dedicated to helping you find the right protection for your home, family, and business — and making the process simple, clear, and stress-free.
Location
Certified by 1st Choice Insurance Services • Apr 05, 2026
1st Choice Insurance Services
4975 W State Road 10, North Judson, IN
46366, United States
Hours
Certified by 1st Choice Insurance Services • Apr 05, 2026
Monday7:30 AM - 4:00 PM
Tuesday7:30 AM - 4:00 PM
Wednesday7:30 AM - 4:00 PM
Thursday7:30 AM - 4:00 PM
Friday7:30 AM - 4:00 PM
SaturdayClosed
SundayClosed
Reviews
4.9
36 reviews
5 stars
33
4 stars
2
3 stars
1
2 stars0
1 star0
- BKBillie KruegerJan 27, 20265.0Very professional, caring and compassionate. Amazing customer service. Carrie & Jamie treated me like family not like a client. Highly recommend 1st Choice Insurance.
- PMPrentis MinixDec 16, 20255.0Always a pleasure working with everyone at 1st choice! They're the best
- RTRhonda TunisOct 31, 20255.0Easy everyone if friendly answers quickly. I know almost everyone that works there in fact I had the opportunity to work with Carrie many many moons ago. Wouldn’t take my insurance anyplace else
- JJJohn JohnsonJul 4, 20225.0Got a quote for my golf cart so I can drive it in town. I want to think them for their time.
Frequently Asked Questions About 1st Choice Insurance Services
What types of insurance coverage does 1st Choice Insurance Services offer?
1st Choice Insurance Services offers auto, homeowners, commercial, life, health, group, farm, agribusiness, Medicare, and affordable insurance policies.
Where is the main office of 1st Choice Insurance Services located?
The main office is located at 4975 W State Road 10, North Judson, Indiana, 46366, United States.
What are the business hours of 1st Choice Insurance Services?
The office is open Monday through Friday from 7:30 AM to 4:00 PM and closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
How can I contact 1st Choice Insurance Services for inquiries or support?
You can call them at +1 574-896-3482, email at megan@1stchoiceinsurance.net, or visit their website at https://www.1stchoiceinsurance.net/.
Does 1st Choice Insurance Services offer assistance outside of business hours?
If the office is closed, you can leave a message through their contact form, and they will respond by the next business day.
Since when has 1st Choice Insurance Services been serving Starke County?
They have proudly served Starke County since 1897, demonstrating long-lasting trust and experience.
What languages are supported by 1st Choice Insurance Services?
The agency provides services in English.
What nearby facilities can customers visit after meeting with 1st Choice Insurance Services?
Customers might visit Judson’s Route 10 Bar and Grill or Burger King for dining, or stop by Patterson Realty if considering real estate options.
Are there nearby educational institutions customers might be interested in?
Yes, nearby schools include North Judson Middle School, North Judson-San Pierre Jr./Sr. High School, and St. Peter Lutheran School, which might be useful for families visiting the area.
What local automotive services are available near 1st Choice Insurance Services?
Nearby automotive services include Collision Auto Body of North Judson LLC, Ken & Tammy’s Collision Auto Body, and Collision Towing & Recovery for repair and roadside assistance needs.
Brand Certified Facts from 1st Choice Insurance Services
This information is certified by 1st Choice Insurance Services and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified April 05, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website