I have lived in the Evansville area all my life.
I have been an insurance agent since 2006 representing Allstate. I enjoy being my own boss helping my staff achieve their goals.
As an Allstate representative, I’m fortunate to be in the position of giving back. My agency is involved with Holly’s House, YMCA of Southwestern Indiana, Dream Center Evansville, Tri-State Food Bank, Simpsons Church Food Pantry and Foster Care in the US. My largest donations over the years have been to St Jude Children's Hospital.
I live here with my wife, Audrey, our children, Hudson, Ava, Mitchell and Elodie. Outside of the office, I enjoy spending time maintaining my property, kayaking, landscaping and studying about history and geography.
David was amazing in helping me set up a plan for exactly what I needed. Very patient with all of my questions, made sure I understood things that I was unaware of, additions/ subtractions to the contract and more questions. Very Excited to work with them!
MM
Michael Nelson (Garots MEM)
Dec 10, 2025
5.0
He is friendly and willing to explain what you need.
BW
Brandi Ward
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
Definitely recommend going through David key directly went to Allstate in general for my car insurance. I was paying over $130 switched to David Key and now I’m paying 99 and some change.
SG
sabrina gash
Nov 3, 2025
5.0
David is absolutely amazing! My husband & I have never felt more confident about our home, auto, and business insurance coverage thanks to his expertise and guidance. He's always available to answer questions, provide personalized advice, and ensure I've got the right protection for my assets. David's professionalism, knowledge, and dedication to his clients are truly exceptional. If you're looking for an insurance agent who truly cares, then I'd highly suggest david key with allstate.
TB
Tony Bell
Oct 30, 2025
1.0
Do not do business with Allstate if you fail to pay, they will turn you over to collections. And then you pay even more money.
Even if you cancel your policy, they still make you pay for additional coverage.Stay clear not good
Frequently Asked Questions About David Key: Allstate Insurance
Where is David Key: Allstate Insurance located?
David Key: Allstate Insurance is located at 1200 N Willow Rd, Ste 204, Evansville, IN 47711, USA.
What types of insurance does David Key: Allstate Insurance offer?
David Key: Allstate Insurance offers auto, home, life, motorcycle, renter's, boat, business, and property insurance policies.
What are the office hours for David Key: Allstate Insurance?
The office is open Monday to Friday from 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM and is closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
How can I schedule an appointment with David Key: Allstate Insurance?
You can schedule an appointment online via their reservation URL at https://agents.allstate.com/david-key-evansville-in.html?section=appointment or call +1 812-421-1925.
Does David Key: Allstate Insurance offer services onsite and online appointments?
Yes, David Key: Allstate Insurance offers both online appointments and onsite services for your convenience.
Who is David Key and what is his connection to the Evansville community?
David Key is a lifelong Evansville resident and an insurance agent since 2006 representing Allstate. He is actively involved in local charities such as Holly’s House, YMCA of Southwestern Indiana, Dream Center Evansville, and St Jude Children’s Hospital.
Which nearby places can I visit when I'm at David Key: Allstate Insurance?
Nearby you can visit LL Flooring and Lumber Liquidators for home improvement needs, or grab a bite at Taco Bell located close by.
How can visiting nearby stores like Lumber Liquidators or LL Flooring complement my visit to David Key: Allstate Insurance?
If you're working on home projects, visiting Lumber Liquidators or LL Flooring nearby can help you pick flooring supplies while discussing insurance options with David Key for your home coverage needs.
Are there any fitness or active lifestyle options near David Key: Allstate Insurance?
Yes, Legacy Elite, a boot camp and sports fitness instruction center, is located nearby to support your active lifestyle.
How can I contact David Key: Allstate Insurance for more information or a quote?
You can contact David Key via phone at +1 812-421-1925 or email DAVID.KEY@allstate.com for more information or insurance quotes.