Nicole Wellman - State Farm Insurance Agent

Reviews

• AK

  Ashley Kolakowski

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Michelle Grindley has great customer service, quick and efficient getting back to her customers.
• SC

  Stephanie Cummings

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Nicole is so knowledgeable about the products she offers and an amazing asset to Mahomet. She and her team made our transition to State Farm seamless and have provided guidance on numerous occasions.
• SK

  Sarah K

  6 days ago
  1.0
  We recently moved our policies to a different agent after a very disappointing experience. After several years with Nicole and consistently making on-time payments, when it came time to actually use our insurance coverage, this office made an already difficult situation worse. Following our house fire, we were unable to reach Nicole and had to make multiple attempts before receiving a return call. During an already traumatic situation, we were left without clear guidance on basic questions, including how and where our deductible would be paid. When we later had a total loss car accident, communication was again extremely limited, with only a text and no meaningful follow-up. We also requested to lower our deductible and went nearly a week without a response. We finally received a response to this when she learned we were transferring our policies to another office, then she ghosted us (I was expecting an apology or some sort of accountability for the unnecessary stress she has caused us over the last six months). Insurance matters most when clients are going through difficult situations. Unfortunately, we did not feel supported, prioritized, or adequately communicated with when we needed help the most.
• AL

  Andrew Lane

  Mar 2, 2026
  5.0
  Nicole was outstanding to work with. She took the time to thoroughly explain the current market shifts & reasons behind changes in both home and auto insurance, which gave me a level of clarity & confidence I haven’t had before. She was patient, knowledgeable, & never rushed the conversation. It’s rare to find someone who can break down complex information so clearly. Because of her, I have no intention of switching from State Farm.
• KV

  Kristen Vogel

  Jan 27, 2026
  5.0
  Nicole is so knowledgeable about insurance and a great asset to the Mahomet community!

Frequently Asked Questions About Nicole Wellman - State Farm Insurance Agent