Since 1925, Mynatt Insurance Agency has delivered peace of mind with insurance products designed to meet the needs of families and businesses in Tampa Bay.
Business Auto Insurance, Business Insurance, Commercial Auto Insurance, Commercial Property Insurance, Employee Dishonesty Bonds, Home Insurance, Independent Insurance Agent, Insurance, Liability Insurance, Life Insurance, Performance Bonds, Permit Bonds, Probate Bonds, Retirement Plans, Auto Insurance, Utility Bonds, General Liability Insurance, Professional Liability Insurance, Cyber Liability Insurance, BOP Insurance, Business Owners Policy Insurance, Insurance for Hairdressers, Barber Insurance, Inland Marine Property Insurance, Medical Business Insurance, Business Income Insurance
Working with Mynatt Insurance Agency has been such a smooth and positive experience. Tim Castle, the owner, is truly committed to helping business owners find the right coverage without breaking the bank. He took the time to understand exactly what I needed and delivered a General Liability policy that not only fit my needs but also beat out other offers I had received.
A big shoutout to Jocelyn Gonzalez as well — she’s incredibly efficient, professional, and kind. Jocelyn was always quick to respond and made the entire process stress-free. You can tell this team genuinely cares about their clients. Highly recommend Mynatt Insurance for anyone needing quality coverage with a personal touch!
KF
Kevin Farrell
Jun 28, 2025
5.0
Been doing business w these guys for 15yrs
Super responsive, great service. I shop them every other year and no one has beat them. Property, general liability and auto for me.
BG
Bob Gerhardt
Jun 13, 2025
5.0
Rebecca has done a great job getting my homeowner's insurance back on board I thank her greatly
DM
Daniel McIntyre
Jun 6, 2025
5.0
The team at Mynatt Insurance are honestly the best. They manage my business and homeowners insurance needs, they will find the best coverages at the best price. Thank you Rebecca Tim and Louis at Mynatt for making insurance as simple as possible.
CR
Cheri Russell
May 16, 2024
5.0
Jocelyn went above and beyond expectations to secure affordable coverage for my Flood policy and I am sure will do as well next time with my Homeowners policy when closer to expiration. . Highly recommend this agency. Cheri Russell
Frequently Asked Questions About Mynatt Insurance Agency
What types of insurance does Mynatt Insurance Agency provide?
Mynatt Insurance Agency offers a variety of insurance including auto, business, commercial, life, health, specialty insurance, and retirement plans.
Where is Mynatt Insurance Agency located?
Mynatt Insurance Agency is located at 1316 W. Busch Blvd., Tampa, FL 33612.
What are the operating hours for Mynatt Insurance Agency?
The agency is open Monday to Friday from 9:00 AM to 12:00 PM and 1:00 PM to 4:45 PM. It is closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
How can I contact Mynatt Insurance Agency?
You can contact them by phone at +1 813-932-5511 or via email at tim@mynattinsurance.com.
Does Mynatt Insurance Agency have an online presence?
Yes, they have a website at https://www.mynattinsurance.com/ and a Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/781632058621675.
Since when has Mynatt Insurance Agency been serving the Tampa Bay area?
Mynatt Insurance Agency has been serving the area since 1925.
Are there any locksmith services near Mynatt Insurance Agency?
Yes, Bay Locksmith is a nearby locksmith service, which may be convenient if you need key or lock services when visiting the area.
What beauty service options are available near Mynatt Insurance Agency?
Simply Raw Salon and Yessy’s Beauty Studio are nearby beauty salons and barber shops where customers can enjoy hair and beauty services before or after visiting the agency.
Are there any nearby medical or chiropractic services around Mynatt Insurance Agency?
Yes, there are several including Precision Spine And Wellness, Tampa Chiropractor Personal Injury Clinic for All Car Accidents, and Healthcare Therapy Center offering chiropractic, physical therapy, and wellness services.
What dining options are available near Mynatt Insurance Agency?
Customers can visit Mi Guatelinda, a nearby Latin American restaurant, which is convenient for a meal before or after insurance consultations.