Store your belongings at Extra Space Storage on 11100 W Cleveland Ave in West Allis, WI today! Our large selection of storage units, drive up access, drive up units, climate controlled units, electronic gate access, manager living on site, exceptional security, ADA compliant, covered drive isles, covered loading bay, deliveries accepted, drive-in building, parking spaces, elevator access, drive up climate controlled units, heated loading bay, warehouse space available, wide drive isles, loading dock, convenient freeway access and helpful staff make finding the right self storage unit for you easy and hassle-free. Experience the professionalism, cleanliness, and commitment to exceptional customer service that Extra Space Storage is known for. Contact us today to reserve your storage unit or set up a time to stop by and take a tour of our facility!
Staff, particularly Jeremiah and Joanna, received high praise for their helpfulness, friendliness, and professionalism.
Facility Condition
The storage facility is consistently noted as clean, well-maintained, and easily accessible.
Pricing Issues
Several customers expressed dissatisfaction with unexpected rent increases shortly after signing leases.
Mixed Experiences
While many customers had positive experiences, some reported serious issues, including lost belongings and poor communication.
Overall Recommendation
Despite some negative feedback, many customers highly recommend the facility for its service and cleanliness.
AH
Austin Hansen
Oct 14, 2025
1.0
If I could give them 0 stars I would. NEVER USE THIS STORAGE FACILITY. They wrongfully sold our families property in an auction and showed ZERO remorse or assistance in helping us recover our belongings.
We were paying for an initial unit. As we had a massive truck load of belongings during non-business hours, our lock on initial unit would not work. We got a hold of Jeremiah who was employed at the time as 'manager' as we were told. He just told us to simply put it in another unit for now as the lock was deemed ineffective and this additional unit was paid for through the end of the year. So my wife contacted him days later to fix our initial lock and move our belongings into our initial storage unit. Jeremiah insisted we could leave our belongings in the additional unit and EVEN GAVE US A KEY for the new unit.
On September 30th when we closed on a new home and were hoping to move our belongings we opened the additional unit and it was completely EMPTY. This company had auctioned off half of our belongings to our name. We had couches, cribs, strollers, TVs, 30 years worth of clothes, unopened wedding gifts, and the list goes on and on and on.
Not only did they auction off this additional unit - but their current staff showed ZERO remorse or compassion and were extremely combative throughout the process. To be clear - we had zero intention of using an additional unit and if they called us we would have paid for the additional unit if needed (even though Jeremiah claimed it was 100% okay to use) - we were never given the opportunity to do so and because of that roughly 30k of belongings were auctioned off and my late fathers belongings, my children's baby boxes, and my wife and my self's baby boxes are in the hands of a stranger as well.
NEVER STORE YOUR BELONGINGS HERE! I'd like to also add these responses are 100p AI generated and not useful whatsoever. The employee who answered my call regarding this issue continuously hangs up and refuses to have a conversation regarding this issue. It'd be great if there was an actual human behind this company Google review responses.
HK
Hannah Kibble
Oct 2, 2025
1.0
If I could give zero stars I would.
I have been using this facility for just over a year and am actively looking for a new storage unit.
My first problem was 2 months after signing for my unit I received a postcard in the mail that my monthly rent was being doubled. I emailed and spoke with multiple people regarding this and I was told I signed a promotional for the first two months and this is the regular price, when I asked for a copy of the lease or receipt stating this they were not able to provide me with one, I did let it go as maybe miscommunication or my mistake until 6 months later I received another postcard and rent was being raised yet again.
Second was the building is set up as a one way in and another way out. The door in was broken for minimum of a week so there was only one way in and out and with it being so narrow inside the building you are not turning around with a trailer or even a truck to get back out or if someone else is trying to get through the opposite way you are.
Third and lastly I received an email and text today that my move out was completed and I was no longer able to access my unit on the app. I called right away and was told that she was just up there and the unit was open and empty so they were under the understanding I had moved out. I told her it should not have been as I have not been there nor have I initiated a move out and requested her to go back on the floor to confirm my unit was in fact not empty. She said she would check and call back. She did call back and state that my unit is closed up and someone wrote down the wrong number for her to inactivate.
For as often and as much as rent goes up it is a very poorly run facility.
II
Isaiah
Sep 20, 2025
5.0
10/10 would store again.
GK
Gene Knaack
Sep 13, 2025
5.0
Rent was reasonable. The storage aisles were always kept clean. Dollys were always available when I needed one. Office personnel were always friendly and helpful, and when there was ever a gate issue I was always notified immediately. Overall I would certainly recommend Extra Space to anyone who needed storage.
CC
Cionella Sumulong (CionellaBella)
Sep 9, 2025
5.0
It’s not my first time renting a storage unit I checked out multiple places prior to coming here. I walked into extra storage facility just to see how it is, so I wasn’t expecting to get a unit on the same day. The assistant store manager Joanna helped me out. She’s awesome, very helpful and knowledgeable. I’m so glad I walked in a perfect day and perfect timing to have Joanna to help me. Because other storage places staff do the bare minimum while Joanna goes beyond to make sure I was familiar and comfortable with the unit and place. She has a great personality and character. I love the place so I secured a unit before it gets taken. I was excited, I felt like I was getting keys to a new apartment. I like that the place is indoors, big, clean, and easily accessible!
Frequently Asked Questions About Extra Space Storage
What storage unit size do I need?
The best way to determine which storage option is right for you is with our helpful Storage Unit Size Guide! It will help you estimate how many boxes and non-packed items, such as furniture and appliances, you can fit into each storage unit.
What type of storage unit do I need?
Many factors determine your best storage solution. Do you want the convenience of a ground-floor unit? Do your belongings need climate control? What about vehicle storage? We have online resources to help you explore these options to find your ideal storage unit.
What are your storage unit prices?
Monthly rates can be found online and vary by facility, unit size, features, and local market. Please use our site search tools to find pricing at a facility near you.
What's the difference between office, access, and gate hours?
The office hours are the hours of operation for the property. During these hours the Store Manager will be available to assist you with your storage needs or moving and packing supplies. The gate hours are the hours of the property, and when your unit can be accessed.
Can I buy boxes or other packing products from Extra Space Storage?
Extra Space Storage offers a variety of moving and packing supplies online and at local facilities for purchase.
What areas does Extra Space Storage serve?
Extra Space Storage serves residents of West Allis, New Berlin, Greenfield, Elm Grove, Wauwatosa, and more.
What is the closest intersection to Extra Space Storage?
Extra Space Storage is located north of the intersection of S 108th St and W Cleveland Ave.
Do you have drive-up storage units?
Yes! Whether you’re moving, storing a vehicle, or using commercial storage, drive-up access is one of the best storage features available at Extra Space Storage! Because you can pull a vehicle right up to your unit, it makes moving large, heavy items—like furniture or equipment—in and out of your unit much easier.
Do you offer climate-controlled storage units?
Most Extra Space Storage facilities offer climate-controlled storage units as an option for anyone storing temperature sensitive items, but there are also standard storage units that don’t include climate control.
Do you offer business storage?
Absolutely! Extra Space Storage is committed to offering business-friendly storage solutions. You can store parts, materials, equipment, vehicles, inventory, and more. Certain locations offer additional business features like delivery acceptance and even some office space available for rent!
What are the gate access hours for Extra Space Storage?
The gate access hours are from 6:00 AM to 10:00 PM every day, Sunday through Saturday.
Where is Extra Space Storage located?
It is located at 11100 W Cleveland Ave, West Allis, WI 53227, USA, north of the intersection of S 108th St and W Cleveland Ave.
Does Extra Space Storage offer climate-controlled units?
Yes, many units are climate-controlled to protect temperature-sensitive items, along with standard units without climate control.
Are there drive-up storage units available?
Yes, Extra Space Storage provides drive-up units allowing easy loading directly from your vehicle.
Can I purchase moving and packing supplies on-site?
Yes, Extra Space Storage offers boxes and packing supplies available online and at local facilities.
What payment methods does Extra Space Storage accept?
Payments can be made via American Express, Apple Pay, Cash, Check, Discover, Invoice, Mastercard, and Visa.
Is there a manager or staff available on-site to assist customers?
Yes, an on-site resident manager and helpful staff are available to assist you.
Are there any notable nearby places that might be of interest when visiting Extra Space Storage?
Nearby places include CubeSmart Self Storage for alternative storage options, Starbucks coffee shops for refreshments, and Kohl's department store for shopping needs.
How can the nearby Starbucks locations help customers visiting Extra Space Storage?
Customers can grab coffee or a snack at nearby Starbucks before or after visiting the storage facility, making their trip more convenient and enjoyable.
What shopping options are available near Extra Space Storage?
Adjacent retail options include Kohl's department store, SEPHORA at Kohl's for beauty products, Marshalls & HomeGoods, HomeGoods, and Dollar Tree Store for various shopping needs.