Store your belongings at Extra Space Storage on 1775 5th Ave in Bay Shore, NY today! Our large selection of storage units, climate controlled units, exceptional security, deliveries accepted, parking spaces, elevator access, RV parking, security access to your floor only, wide drive isles, commercial tenants, loading dock, convenient freeway access and helpful staff make finding the right self storage unit for you easy and hassle-free. Experience the professionalism, cleanliness, and commitment to exceptional customer service that Extra Space Storage is known for. Contact us today to reserve your storage unit or set up a time to stop by and take a tour of our facility!
Explore offerings from Extra Space Storage on 1775 5th Ave in Bay Shore, with popular services available at this location.
7569 Services
10 items
Services
Self Storage
Extra Space Storage offers a wide range of secure self storage solutions for residential and commercial needs. Our storage units are rented on a month-to-month basis and come in a variety of sizes from 5x5 to 10x30 (with additional sizing available).
Online Payments
Extra Space Storage makes it easy to pay your storage rental bill online. Simply log into your account to access statements, make a payment, and more. You can make one-time online payments or even set up recurring payments.
Packing & Moving Supplies
Extra Space Storage sells packing and moving supplies like boxes, bubble wrap, packing tape, rope, moving kits, and more. We have all of the moving supplies you need for a successful move!
Climate Controlling
Climate control at Extra Space Storage can help protect sensitive items from extreme temperatures. These units typically stay between 55 and 80 degrees year-round.
Package Placement
Extra Space Storage facilities can accept package deliveries on behalf of customers. For more information about package acceptance and placement, contact our team!
Deliveries Accepted
Some Extra Space Storage locations allow deliveries to be accepted. With delivery acceptance, a staff member will be available to accept your mail and keep it in a secure place until you pick it up.
RV Parking
Depending on the facility, Extra Space Storage offers indoor, outdoor, or covered RV parking. Outdoor parking is the most common option for RV storage, with units ranging from 8x20 to 8x40 (and sometimes larger)!
Individual Floor Access
Individual floor access is a security feature that only allows Extra Space Storage customers to have access to the floor their self storage unit is on. This security measure helps our facility managers keep track of who is coming and going from the facility.
Wide Drive Aisles
Wide-drive aisles provide plenty of space for larger vehicles and moving trucks to get in and out of Extra Space Storage when accessing outdoor and drive-up storage units.
Commercial Use Allowed
Extra Space Storage offers small and large storage units for business use. Commercial storage features can include extended access hours, climate control, warehouse space, and more. Commercial storage is a great solution if your business has a surplus of supplies or inventory.
Reviews
4.7
860 reviews
5 stars
769
4 stars
34
3 stars
16
2 stars
13
1 star
28
SM
Steve Mays
Aug 6, 2026
5.0
Faith is very knowledgeable of her job and very professional. Great experience.
ME
Meg Euncie
Aug 1, 2026
5.0
First time looking for storage space and stopped in on a Saturday , I was assisted by Faith!, She was really sweet, friendly and helpful. She explained everything on how extra storage works, I had a pleasant experience.
CG
Carl Gayle
Jul 29, 2026
5.0
Shavon and team was amazing ! They answered all of my questions and made me feel comfortable as I’m a new resident in the area. Thanks so much !!!!!!
MR
Michael Rizzo
Jul 23, 2026
5.0
The staff especially Siobhan (hope i spelled it correctly) have always been great. They made my rental and my switching to another closer unit a breeze.
SO
seungchul oh
Jul 18, 2026
5.0
Thank you so much for all your help.
You did an amazing job helping me solve a very difficult situation, and you've been incredibly kind throughout the whole process.
There were some complicated circumstances, and some of the miscommunication was my fault because my English is limited. Even so, you were very patient, explained everything clearly, and helped resolve the misunderstandings.
I truly appreciate your kindness, patience, and professionalism. Thank you again for everything!
Faith and Shiobhan,
Thank you both so much once again. I truly appreciate all of your help and kindness. You made a difficult situation much easier, and I'm very grateful for everything you did for me.
Frequently Asked Questions About Extra Space Storage
What storage unit size do I need?
The best way to determine which storage option is right for you is with our helpful Storage Unit Size Guide! It will help you estimate how many boxes and non-packed items, such as furniture and appliances, you can fit into each storage unit.
What type of storage unit do I need?
Many factors determine your best storage solution. Do you want the convenience of a ground-floor unit? Do your belongings need climate control? What about vehicle storage? We have online resources to help you explore these options to find your ideal storage unit.
What are your storage unit prices?
Monthly rates can be found online and vary by facility, unit size, features, and local market. Please use our site search tools to find pricing at a facility near you.
What's the difference between office, access, and gate hours?
The office hours are the hours of operation for the property. During these hours the Store Manager will be available to assist you with your storage needs or moving and packing supplies. The gate hours are the hours of the property, and when your unit can be accessed.
Can I buy boxes or other packing products from Extra Space Storage?
Extra Space Storage offers a variety of moving and packing supplies online and at local facilities for purchase.
What areas does Extra Space Storage serve?
Extra Space Storage serves residents of Bay Shore, Brentwood, North Bay Shore, Pine Aire, Islip, and more.
What is the closest intersection to Extra Space Storage?
Extra Space Storage is located at the corner of Candlewood Rd and 5th Ave.
Do you offer climate-controlled storage units?
Most Extra Space Storage facilities offer climate-controlled storage units as an option for anyone storing temperature sensitive items, but there are also standard storage units that don’t include climate control.
Do you offer RV storage solutions?
Yes! At Extra Space Storage we offer outdoor parking, covered parking, and indoor storage solutions for RVs of all sizes. Whether you’re leaving an RV in storage long term or simply need a place to park an RV between uses, we offer a flexible option with month-to-month leases so you can store for as long as you need.
Do you offer boat storage solutions?
Yes! At Extra Space Storage we offer outdoor parking, covered parking, and indoor storage solutions for boats of all sizes.
Brand Certified Facts from Extra Space Storage
This information is certified by Extra Space Storage and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified August 23, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including:
