Store your belongings at Extra Space Storage on 225 Howells Rd in Bay Shore, NY today! Our large selection of storage units, climate controlled units, electronic gate access, manager living on site, exceptional security, ADA compliant, covered loading bay, deliveries accepted, parking spaces, elevator access, security access to your floor only, heated loading bay, wide drive isles, loading dock, convenient freeway access and helpful staff make finding the right self storage unit for you easy and hassle-free. Experience the professionalism, cleanliness, and commitment to exceptional customer service that Extra Space Storage is known for. Contact us today to reserve your storage unit or set up a time to stop by and take a tour of our facility!
Staff, particularly Manny and Will, received high praise for being friendly, helpful, and professional throughout the rental process.
Cleanliness
The facility is consistently described as clean, well-maintained, and secure, contributing to a positive customer experience.
Pricing Issues
Several customers expressed dissatisfaction with unexpected price increases, leading to frustration and concerns about transparency.
Ease of Process
Many reviews highlighted the quick and easy rental process, with seamless sign-up and access to units.
Overall Satisfaction
Most customers reported a positive experience and expressed willingness to recommend the storage facility to others.
AP
Andrea P
Nov 10, 2025
5.0
Super clean facility, safe And temperature is always perfect. I’ve had a unit For about a year and just upgraded to a larger one. The manager at this facility has been extremely helpful and answered my questions right away. Highly recommend it If you are considering getting a unit here.
AD
Alycia DeBlase
Nov 6, 2025
5.0
Easy sign up/ move in.
GG
Gary Guy
Oct 30, 2025
5.0
I would recommend this storage company to anyone I know. They are polite, and always keep in contact with, letting you know what’s happening month to month. Will is the associate who helped me, 💯% helpful and very punctual. To anyone thinking of a professional storage company to use” I highly recommend this one.
Frequently Asked Questions About Extra Space Storage
What storage unit size do I need?
The best way to determine which storage option is right for you is with our helpful Storage Unit Size Guide! It will help you estimate how many boxes and non-packed items, such as furniture and appliances, you can fit into each storage unit.
What type of storage unit do I need?
Many factors determine your best storage solution. Do you want the convenience of a ground-floor unit? Do your belongings need climate control? What about vehicle storage? We have online resources to help you explore these options to find your ideal storage unit.
What are your storage unit prices?
Monthly rates can be found online and vary by facility, unit size, features, and local market. Please use our site search tools to find pricing at a facility near you.
What's the difference between office, access, and gate hours?
The office hours are the hours of operation for the property. During these hours the Store Manager will be available to assist you with your storage needs or moving and packing supplies. The gate hours are the hours of the property, and when your unit can be accessed.
Can I buy boxes or other packing products from Extra Space Storage?
Extra Space Storage offers a variety of moving and packing supplies online and at local facilities for purchase.
What areas does Extra Space Storage serve?
Extra Space Storage serves businesses and residents in the Bay Shore area, including those near Baywood, Brightwaters, North Babylon, Deer Park, Brentwood, and West Islip.
What is the closest intersection to Extra Space Storage?
Extra Space Storage is located near the intersection of Muncey Rd and Howells Rd.
Do you offer climate-controlled storage units?
Most Extra Space Storage facilities offer climate-controlled storage units as an option for anyone storing temperature sensitive items, but there are also standard storage units that don’t include climate control.
Do you offer business storage?
Absolutely! Extra Space Storage is committed to offering business-friendly storage solutions. You can store parts, materials, equipment, vehicles, inventory, and more. Certain locations offer additional business features like delivery acceptance and even some office space available for rent!
Are moving carts or dollies provided?
Nearly all Extra Space Storage facilities that offer indoor storage units with access through a hallway have push carts. If you need a push cart to transport your belongings, please let the facility manager know, and they will be happy to assist you.
What are the access hours for Extra Space Storage in Bay Shore, NY?
Extra Space Storage is open daily from 6:00 AM to 10:00 PM, including weekends.
What types of storage units does Extra Space Storage offer?
Extra Space Storage offers a large selection of storage units including climate-controlled options, vehicle storage, and standard units.
How do I determine the right storage unit size for my needs?
Use Extra Space Storage's Storage Unit Size Guide to estimate how many boxes and items like furniture can fit into each unit size.
Does Extra Space Storage provide moving and packing supplies?
Yes, they offer moving and packing supplies both online and at the facility for purchase.
Is there an on-site manager available at Extra Space Storage?
Yes, an on-site resident manager is available to assist customers with their storage needs.
Can I access my storage unit at any time?
You can access your unit daily between 6:00 AM and 10:00 PM, aligning with the gate hours.
What payment options does Extra Space Storage accept?
They accept American Express, Apple Pay, cash, check, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
What are some nearby facilities or services near Extra Space Storage?
Nearby places include Life Storage - Bay Shore, British Swim School - Long Island, World GYM, and several car rental agencies like Budget and Avis.
How can nearby transit or rental services help when visiting Extra Space Storage?
Nearby car rental agencies such as Budget Rent A Car and Avis can provide transportation options to reach Extra Space Storage with ease.
Are there any nearby attractions or places to visit when using Extra Space Storage?
After your storage visit, you might enjoy nearby places like Mulberry Street Bay Shore for Italian dining or Carvel Ice Cream for a treat.