Neenah-Menasha YMCA

Reviews

• KV

  Kledi Vata

  Jul 16, 2026
  1.0
  When you come up to my fiance and make her uncomfortable that’s when I’ll start talking. Been coming to the YMCA for a while now and every-time I go my fiance wears a sports bra and sweats. Was it an issue for the last 2 years, no, but did they make it an issue, yes. If they had felt that this was an issue it would’ve been addressed a while ago but this is what people who have no lives have to do. Specifically a male employee checking my fiance out then going to his female coworker to let her know to put a shirt on. I’ve always seen the how this male has had it out for us and today we made it final that we will never go again and remove our memberships. It was not a pleasure and thank you guys for giving me the final straw! (FYI at the Fox West YMCA a 50 year old man came up to my fiance as I was using the restroom to try and hit on her, truthfully embarrassing and I would call these guys the word but google will take it down)
• HS

  Helen Smith

  Jul 16, 2026
  1.0
  I’ve been working out at the Neenah YMCA for approximately three years, and during that time I have consistently worn similar workout attire without any employee ever informing me that wearing a sports bra violated the dress code. If this has truly been a policy, it should have been communicated much earlier rather than being addressed in the middle of my workout. Enforcing a rule that has never been clearly communicated creates unnecessary confusion and frustration for members. I would also recommend posting the dress code in a visible location, such as the front desk or the whiteboard in the fitness area, so all members are aware of the expectations before they begin their workouts. Unfortunately, this experience has left me feeling unwelcome, and because of how the situation was handled, I’ve decided to cancel my membership and join VASA Fitness instead. I hope the YMCA will take this feedback into consideration and improve the way policies are communicated and enforced in the future.
• DT

  Doug Tice

  Jul 14, 2026
  2.0
  Was told different rules by different staff members in the same area less then 30 minutes apart. Hard to know which to follow.
• LK

  Lori Kelley

  Jul 7, 2026
  1.0
  This place makes it literally impossible to cancel your membership. Their website or online account does not work for this purpose and when you call and ask them to do it they just tell you to go to the website but when you tell them the website doesn't work they say that they forwarded the information to the person in charge of accounts and that you will still be charged the following month, but after that no more charges... but then you're still charged for another three or four months! It's not even worth the hassle! I'm just calling my bank and doing a chargeback. Also if you're on the younger side you might want to keep your eyes fully shut when you're in the locker room because there's 75 year old overweight ladies walking around completely butt naked like it don't even matter. At least stay by your locker in a corner, if you're going to be completely naked. There's no reason to walk around the entire room without a towel. It's definitely a site for sore eyes! Also if you plan on going to the jacuzzi good luck because half the time it's either shut down or the water is only half full.
• AA

  A

  Jun 10, 2026
  3.0
  Its been a while since we have been here (due to poor employees we didnt come here for a long time) its a bit better than before but some employees at the front shouldn't be in the front if they are going to be mean and act like they dont want to be there. I get it, it can get hectic and crazy but you're the face of Y, you're the first face someone's walks in to see. At least act like you want to work there. 🙂 to add on I like it when i was the frist one waiting to get help but than "S" ignored me and helped all the other guest that came after me. 😆 at least she said "have a nice day" when we left. I understand this place has been running for a long time but im curious to how they pass the health department? Pools have black mold, rust and breaking apart. Lockers rooms are rusty and bathroom sinks are almost falling off the wall and so much more.

Frequently Asked Questions About Neenah-Menasha YMCA