Business Details
About
Pizza Restaurant
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.6
304 reviews
5 stars
230
4 stars
46
3 stars
11
2 stars
5
1 star
12
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Many customers praised the food as delicious, particularly the pizza and calzones, although some noted inconsistencies in preparation and freshness.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted poor service experiences, including long wait times for orders and inattentive staff, particularly during busy periods.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's ambiance received positive remarks, with many customers appreciating the local charm and family-friendly environment.
Pricing
Customers generally found the pricing to be fair, though some felt that certain items did not justify their cost.
Inconsistent Experience
Feedback indicated a mix of experiences, with some customers having excellent visits while others reported significant issues, particularly after a change in ownership.
- DJDuane JonesOct 23, 20255.0The food was fantastic and fair priced
- SHSandy HildenbrandOct 11, 20251.0Put in online order, when hubby got there to pickup it up 4 minutes before it was to be done, they didn’t even have the order. Then it took an extra 30 minutes for them to make the pizza. Frozen pizza from the store is better! Don’t waste you money on $30 pizza.
- WOWendy OsmotherlySep 13, 20255.0Polite, wonderful service, excellent food!
- RGRita GarciaAug 31, 20251.0I ordered 2,large pizzas the guy said it would take 35 minutes, we went to pick it up they had my daughter and I wait an extra 10 minutes it wasn’t ready yet. Then when we did get it, we brought it home, it was doughy . I paid 40.00 for 2 large pizzas. They needed to cook it longer.
- RSRichard SchneiderAug 14, 20251.0Pulled up to this place they came out and told me they were closing it was 7:30 pm on 8/14 can't even stay open for their posted hours
Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza Barn
What are the operating hours of Pizza Barn?
Pizza Barn is open from 2:00 PM to 10:00 PM Monday through Saturday, and from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Sunday.
During what hours is takeout available at Pizza Barn?
Takeout service is available from 2:30 PM to 9:30 PM Monday through Saturday, and from 11:30 AM to 9:30 PM on Sunday.
Can I have my order delivered from Pizza Barn?
Yes, Pizza Barn offers delivery service every day during delivery hours: 2:30 PM to 9:30 PM Monday through Saturday, and 11:30 AM to 9:30 PM on Sunday.
Does Pizza Barn offer in-store pickup for orders?
Yes, Pizza Barn offers in-store pickup as one of their services.
Where is Pizza Barn located?
Pizza Barn is located at 66 Old US Hwy 85, Newcastle, WY 82701, United States.
How can I view the Pizza Barn menu online?
You can view the menu on their website at https://pizzabarn.co/menu.
What types of cuisine does Pizza Barn serve?
Pizza Barn serves pizza, Italian, American, hamburger dishes, and family-style meals.
I am visiting Seventh-Day Adventist Church nearby. How close is Pizza Barn for a meal before or after?
Pizza Barn is close to the Seventh-Day Adventist Church, making it a convenient place to enjoy a meal before or after your visit to the church.
Are there pet services near Pizza Barn if I want to groom my dog before dining?
Yes, Dog Gone Salon, a pet groomer and pet store, is located near Pizza Barn, so you can easily combine pet care with your visit.
Is there a church close to Pizza Barn where I can attend a service before grabbing a meal?
Gateway Fellowship Church is nearby Pizza Barn, providing an option to attend a service before or after dining at Pizza Barn.