Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club

Reviews

• CR

  Claudia Renaud

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Best fish fry we’ve ever had!! Had a wonderful server, Rose, who helped us with beverage selections. She was attentive to us throughout the meal and it was fun conversing with her about the menu and our choices. Many other servers helped to deliver the food in a timely manner. Highly suggest for that Supper Club vibe!
• DB

  Deirdre Bramberg

  4 days ago
  5.0
  What a fabulous supper club in the heart of Wauwatosa village. Got us started out with an old fashioned cuz after all we are in Wisconsin I decided to go with the chef's recommendation of the prime rib sandwich. Oh my goodness! Such delicious tender juicy moist sliced prime rib on a beautiful bun with just the right amount of horseradish so big. I could only eat half and I'm dreaming about my next half a sandwich for lunch tomorrow. Make a point to check this out. They have outdoor dining as well. I'm going to go back for dinner because I was so impressed the staff was attentive and let us be when we needed to as we were with some friends celebrating a birthday
• RH

  Rafael Hidalgo

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  First timer here. Mercedes was our server and was very attentive throughout our whole experience. Food and drinks were good and tasty. Let us bring a cake in for a birthday celebration. That was very kind. Overall a great place with hard working staff. The ambiance was perfect for a Sunday.
• TR

  Tom Remy

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  What a great place. The service the food the atmosphere were amazing. We had so much fun. We planed to go for a quick dinner at the bar. We had such a fun time talking with the bartenders and other guests around us we ended up staying 3.5 hours. The atmosphere is very cool. Made to look like a supper club from up north Wisconsin. Everywhere you look there is some fun decor. We drinks were top notch. I had a whiskey old fashioned and it was perfect. My wife had a Bloody Mary that was very good as well. We loved all the menu items. So many great options. It took us a half an hour to decide what we wanted. We started with the deviled eggs and a bowl of the wild rice clam chowder. Both were delicious. We shared a chicken schnitzel. It was equally as good, nothing left on our plates. I highly recommend the Buckatabon. I can’t say enough about the service. I will add the only down side is the parking. We had to drive around a bit to find a spot. Can’t wait to go back.
• AK

  Andy Kristensen

  Mar 19, 2026
  5.0
  What an absolutely delightful little supper club in the heart of Wauwatosa. The ambiance is casual and warm (I especially love the old school decor and Christmas lights strung throughout), the food was amazing (I got one of their burgers; highly recommend the double patties with some bacon added!), and the service was outstanding. Our waitress was Emmaline, and she was easily the best waitress I’ve had over the past few months. I believe it’s service and quality of food that set restaurants apart, and Buckatabon exceeds expectations in both categories. Phenomenal place!

Frequently Asked Questions About Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club