Jimmy John's

3.6
189 reviews

About

Sandwich Restaurant

Location

Jimmy John's
1845 Park Ave, Plover, WI
54467, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.6
189 reviews
5 stars
79
4 stars
45
3 stars
13
2 stars
13
1 star
39

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Order Accuracy

Many customers reported issues with incorrect orders and missing items, leading to frustration.

Service Quality

Service experiences varied significantly, with some praising friendly staff while others noted rudeness and poor management.

Food Quality

While some customers enjoyed the sandwiches, others criticized them for being skimpy or not meeting expectations.

Speed of Service

Customers experienced inconsistent service speed, with some noting quick service while others reported long wait times.
  • SO
    Stacey Otto
    Nov 30, 2025
    2.0
    Forgot one of our subs. Ordered 5 sandwiches and only got 4. They also forgot to put mayo on my #17 sub.
  • KF
    K. F.
    Oct 10, 2025
    5.0
    Najlepsze kanapki jakie jadłem podczas pobytu w USA 💪
  • PZ
    Pam Zindars
    Oct 9, 2025
    1.0
    Sandwich was the size of the little john. Not the size of other stores. Staff very loud talking about world burning up. One worker saying she was hungry and oh, I can take another pill VERY loud. Worst experience at a Jimmy John's. Needs better management!!!
  • AT
    Aniya Tovar
    Sep 27, 2025
    1.0
    Service wasn’t great. Sandwiches very bland. Somebody with Paralysis and missing a left leg woulda done better. Just saying.
  • KK
    Kosucha
    Sep 2, 2025
    4.0
    This is broken into two parts from two different experiences at two different times of the day. Decided to try it to see for myself if the other reviews were true. Day 1 (Morning) Ordered on the app for pickup. Got a Jimmy Cubano and customized it with tomatoes, Jimmy Peppers, and onions. Sandwich was made strangely fast, so that was off putting. Opened the sandwich, and it was a basic Jimmy Cubano. No extras, almost as if their brain is hard-wired to only make sandwiches as a default, and not with customization. Im glad i didn't pay for the extras. When i walked in, they all seemed like they hated their jobs. Wasnt greeted at all, just asked what i wanted when I got to the counter. You could tell the motivation was an absolute zero. Day 2 (Late Afternoon) Decided to give them another shot because I do love the sandwiches here. Decided to get the exact same thing i ordered before, except in the Box Lunch. Since i work next door, I tend to send the order while im on the clock and pick it up when i get the notification that its ready for pickup. Today that notification popped up minutes later, so I was nervous they just threw it together to get it done. I pulled up and walked in the same. This time it was pretty lively, i was greeted by a taller guy and a blonde girl, who were both extremely nice. They were quick to getting me my pickup order and I was on my way. Everything was PERFECT. Sandwich was actually customized as ordered this time. It seems to me that the PM crew is definitely a night and day difference to the AM crew, so going after around 2PM seems to be the optimal time to go.