Who's on Third

Reviews

• MG

  M G

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Great service & atmosphere! I had the cheese curds & blackberry cider, both were delicious! Hopped on a ride to the ballgame which was so fun. Would 10/10 recommend all the above.
• JH

  Jason H

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Came solely for the shuttle to the Brewers game, and picked it over other bars because the shuttle logistics were perfectly described on their website. Grabbed a beer from the fast and attentive bartender. The shuttle process was also excellent with the driver announcing shuttle departures multiple times. For an out of towner, it was exactly what I wanted. In my opinion, it is the only way to get to and from a brewers game from downtown. If you have any anxiety about it, don’t. Have a beer, ride the shuttle, enjoy the game
• KS

  Kevin Spaeth

  3 days ago
  5.0
  I just came back from a conference at Baird Center. We discovered Who's On Third the first night. Avery and Kat were awesome. We made friends with one of the locals, Orian and played bar dice. Avery said they were the best wings in town but the fryers had been shut down by then. It was such a good night for the rest of the conference we said "all roads lead to (Who's on) Third". That was our meeting spot for when everyone was done with their events or dinners. I learned to cook by make chicken wings in the early 90s. I knew I had to try some. So me and a few dudes snuck away from a bland conference lunch and went over. Avery was the bartender for the lunch shift. I took her suggestion of 6 honey bacon and 6 schiracha ginger. They were fantastic. Turns out Averys boyfriend grew up where I was cooking wings in Jersey and knew the joint. His mom might have gone to Seton Hall with my older brother. That's how friendly and nice she was We talked about cool things. We closed the bar down that night. Great old fashions! The conference ended at noon the next day so another bunch of us went back for more wings and loaded tots before heading to the airport
• RS

  Rachel Serritella

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  my boyfriend and i came in friday night and we had grace as our bartender, her positivity and knowledge of the menu created a great experience for both of us! cant wait to come back to see her and try more custom cocktails
• VP

  Viv Park

  Mar 12, 2026
  5.0
  Thomas was our amazing server for the night. Really liked his laid back, but friendly and helpful demeanor, as well as his professionalism in accommodating our needs. Made our experience super easy and perfectly pleasant. Grilled wings Ooh, these were perfectly grilled. Very tasty sauce (hot honey garlic, at Thomas’ recommendation) that wasn’t overdone or underdone - just the right amount. I usually get my wings naked because so many places go wrong with the amount of sauce (usually just too drenched), but since we were on a timeline tonight, we just ordered without asking for anything else. So glad we did! By the way, not fried wings, so not super crunchy on the outside but still crispy and not at all soggy. And super moist, perfect temp inside. Tap Guinness Perfectly poured with just the right amount of cream on top. Hany is usually an IPA man, and went Guinness this time and did not regret it! Overall, this place is a little bit further away than the new hopping bars on the Deer District. I wanted to try the new places, so kept on trying them while hubby wanted to keep coming back here… and I’m glad we did this time. Sometimes new is good, but they’ve got it right here - I don’t have to keep searching! Oh just one thing - all the TVs in the bar, and they have to play 60 minutes? Without captions? lol