Business Details
About
Pizza RestaurantRestaurantMarcus Hotels & Resorts
This small, neighborhood pizza joint relishes in the simple pleasures. Proof Pizza is a fast-casual Neapolitan-style pizza joint that balances old-world character and modern design, resulting in the best pizza in downtown Milwaukee.
Featuring classic flavors and techniques, modern ambiance, and casual service, Proof serves traditional Neapolitan pizza, sandwiches, Italian snacks, and salads alongside a fun selection of Italian sodas.
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Requires reservationsNot available
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.1
212 reviews
5 stars
131
4 stars
32
3 stars
14
2 stars
16
1 star
19
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Pizza Quality
Customers praised the flavor and freshness of the pizza, but many noted issues with sogginess and undercooking.
Service Experience
Feedback on service was mixed; while some found staff friendly and accommodating, others reported poor attitudes and lack of attentiveness.
Atmosphere
The dining area is often described as noisy and lacking sufficient seating, which detracted from the overall experience.
Value for Money
Several customers felt the prices were high relative to the quality and portion sizes of the food.
- SWSam WDec 27, 20255.0We got pizzas here on Christmas evening and while I didn't catch their names, shout out to the 2 employees who were handling the busy night of orders well. Yummy pizzas
- MWMichael WaiteDec 18, 20255.0Located within St. Kate's Hotel is this delightful pizzeria. Dough freshly made in front of you. Lots of healthy & delectable toppings. First time trying was delicious and I'll be back. The CSMO 17 was delish!
- SKSue Grace KrokoszNov 13, 20253.0Really weird experience. No place to sit really. Pizzas take almost half an hour. No clue what their target market is because it’s not convenient if you wanna grab a quick bite of pizza and then go to the live shows over at the associate theater complex. It wasn’t bad, just really not worth a repeat.
- MVMadhu ValikkodathOct 29, 20255.0Really good pie
- ACAlessia CataniaOct 23, 20255.0Questo posto è un angolo di paradiso della VERA pizza Italiana. La qualità della pasta e degli ingredienti è eccellente e il tutto risulta perfetto. I tempi di attesa sono bassissimi. Quindi se state cercando la vera pizza napoletana qui a Milwaukee questo è il posto dove andare. Ps: chi dice che la pizza non è cotta farebbe meglio ad andare a mangiare una pizza americana. Peace and love!
Frequently Asked Questions About Proof Pizza
Where is Proof Pizza located in Milwaukee?
Proof Pizza is located at 139 E. Kilbourn, Downtown Milwaukee, WI 53202, with the entrance on Water Street.
What are the operating hours for Proof Pizza?
Proof Pizza is open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to midnight on Friday and Saturday.
What types of food does Proof Pizza serve?
Proof Pizza serves traditional Neapolitan-style pizzas, sandwiches, Italian snacks, salads, and a selection of Italian sodas.
Does Proof Pizza offer pickup and delivery services?
Yes, Proof Pizza offers both in-store pickup and curbside pickup options.
Is Proof Pizza wheelchair accessible?
Yes, Proof Pizza has a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, seating, and restrooms to accommodate all guests.
Does Proof Pizza have a bar and serve alcohol?
Yes, Proof Pizza has an onsite bar and serves alcohol, including beer.
Can families and children dine at Proof Pizza?
Yes, Proof Pizza welcomes families and children and provides a welcoming environment for all guests.
What nearby hotels can guests find close to Proof Pizza?
Guests near Proof Pizza can find nearby hotels such as Saint Kate - The Arts Hotel and InterContinental Milwaukee for convenient accommodations.
Are there bars or lounges close to Proof Pizza for after-dinner drinks?
Yes, nearby options for drinks include CLEAR cocktail bar, Giggly at Saint Kate lounge, The Bar at Saint Kate, The Dark Room at Saint Kate, and Giggly Champagne & Wine Bar.
What nearby attractions could I visit before or after dining at Proof Pizza?
You can explore nearby attractions such as Untapped Tours for sightseeing and The Living Rainbow gift shop for unique shopping experiences around Downtown Milwaukee.