At Papa Johns Pizza in Milwaukee, WI, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Milwaukee pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Milwaukee or stop by 1611 West Wells Street for carryout to order the best pizza in Milwaukee, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Numerous reviews highlighted poor customer service, including rude staff, unprofessional management, and long wait times for assistance.
Order Accuracy
Many customers reported issues with incorrect orders, including wrong toppings and missing items, leading to significant dissatisfaction.
Food Quality
Several reviews mentioned undercooked or poorly prepared food, with complaints about the pizza being raw, burnt, or lacking expected ingredients.
Safety Concerns
Customers expressed serious concerns about safety at the location, citing incidents of staff being threatened and overall unsafe conditions.
Delivery Issues
Frequent complaints about delayed deliveries, canceled orders, and lack of communication regarding order status were noted.
TC
Teresa L Coleman
3 days ago
1.0
Pizza was not prepared as ordered and was Luke warm. When I was attempting to inquire about how long it was sitting the employee walked away and started talking to another employee..very disappointed with service and food presentation !! No more Pappa Johns !
YG
Yg G
Dec 20, 2025
1.0
I am a Marquette student that orders here often and very familiar with the staff, they are always very kind. But what I don’t like is the safety of this location, from hearing one of my favorites being fired for being assaulted and witnessing the manager and staff being threatened for telling a customer to leave. I will be reporting this to the Better Business Bureau for unsafe conditions.
AT
Antonio Tate
Dec 18, 2025
1.0
Nothing was safe about this store the young lady that worked there need to get fired asap she was so wrong she need to get fired
JT
Joshua Trembly
Dec 5, 2025
1.0
Awful experience. I ordered a pizza via phone and when I went to pick up the pizza we waited for 45 minutes and no could give use our pizza. Staff was very slow and not helpful.
CA
Christopher Archer
Dec 1, 2025
1.0
Doors locked at pick-up. Workers were in no rush to let me in. Person that “helped” me was talking to someone on their personal cell and were slow to get my order. Unlikely to return to this location.
What are the delivery hours for Papa Johns Pizza in Milwaukee?
Delivery is available Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 9:30 AM to 1:00 AM, and on Friday and Saturday from 9:30 AM to 3:00 AM.
Does Papa Johns Pizza offer takeout services?
Yes, Papa Johns Pizza offers takeout with the same hours as delivery: 9:30 AM to 1:00 AM on weekdays and Sunday, and until 3:00 AM on Friday and Saturday.
How can I place an order for carryout or delivery from Papa Johns Pizza?
You can order online for carryout or delivery through their website or mobile apps available on the Apple App Store and Google Play Store.
What types of food products does Papa Johns Pizza offer at this location?
They offer pizza, wings, desserts, breadsticks, cheesesticks, and beverages.
Does Papa Johns Pizza provide no-contact delivery service?
Yes, they offer no-contact delivery service to ensure safety and convenience.
Where is Papa Johns Pizza located in Milwaukee?
It is located at 1611 West Wells Street, Milwaukee, WI, 53233, USA.
Are there nearby dining options close to Papa Johns Pizza?
Yes, nearby dining options include Murphy's Irish Pub, Gray Jett Cafe, Sobelman's burger restaurant, Broken Yolk II for breakfast, and Qdoba Mexican Grill.
Are there other pizza places near Papa Johns Pizza at 1611 West Wells Street?
Yes, nearby pizza options include Angelo's Pizza and another Papa John's Pizza location.
What nearby facilities might be of interest to visitors after their meal at Papa Johns Pizza?
Visitors might want to check out the Marquette University Institute for the Transformation of Learning or the Marquette University Union Sports Annex for educational and recreational activities.
Can I find grocery or convenience stores near Papa Johns Pizza for additional shopping needs?
Yes, nearby grocery and convenience stores include 7-Eleven, Sendik's Food Market, and Open Pantry Food Marts.