Mason Street Grill in downtown Milwaukee, is a classic American Grill serving high-quality wood grilled steaks, amazing sandwiches and house-made desserts. With comfortable booths, a welcoming staff and a warm atmosphere, you’re invited to settle in and stay for a while.
Many customers praised the attentive and friendly service from various staff members, highlighting specific servers like Noah, Thor, and Aiden.
Food Quality
Overall, the food received high marks for flavor and preparation, particularly the steaks and desserts, although some reviews noted inconsistencies in certain dishes.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's ambiance was frequently described as inviting and elegant, contributing positively to the dining experience.
Experience Consistency
While many reviews were overwhelmingly positive, a few customers reported issues with service delays and food quality, indicating some inconsistency in the overall experience.
EL
erik lacy
6 days ago
2.0
Came out to Mason Street; and stayed over Christmas; we were having a good time but we were sat in the back by the kitchen a bit loud by the dishwasher but fine. Alanna was nice enough; however the other guy that was walking around, shirt half out, poorly dressed in what looked like slippers??? clearing tables was very odd. He would take out drinks before we would finish them! Which with a clear line of sight to the dishwasher I figured out it was to finish my cocktail in the back. It was hard to watch.
CB
Cris Buhay
Jan 6, 2026
1.0
I popped in over the Christmas week, early in the evening; food is always good and the staff is very friendly, Andrea was very nice. We did not like the short dark haired woman who seemed to be the Manager? She was brutally rude to her staff, they seemed afraid of her, it made the night awkward and unpleasant.
MK
Marilyn Kaslofski
Dec 30, 2025
5.0
Christmas dinner, delicious.! Loved that they had a prix fixe but also their regular menu. Our server Elle was delightful and several of the management team checked in with us. First time at the counter seating overlooking the kitchen, such fun. This place is great. Highly recommend
DK
David Kopecky
Dec 26, 2025
5.0
We are regulars in Mason Street Grill and it was wonderful that everyone came by our table to wish us happy holidays. Graham took great care of us and we always are made to feel that all of our severs ( plus bar staff ) are genuinely happy to see us.
SM
Somni Moten
Dec 12, 2025
4.0
I went here for Christmas dinner. It was amazing. The prime rib was a perfect medium rare, and had a nice crust. The Bisque was something I had never had before and had a nice touch. The carrot cake was a little crunchy. It tasted as it the carrots weren't freshly grated. Otherwise, everything was spectacular. I can't wait to go back for new years eve and try the elk.
Update: the menu on the website had none of the entrees as the in person menu for new years eve. I was all excited for the elk with pierogis and they didn't have it. What I had was amazing, but I feel like it wouldn't have compared to their offerings online, especially for $125. I tried both of the menus and Christmas dinner was definitely better in my book. The lobster Bisque was brown and not orange which was different for me and it didn't exude lobster flavor.
Frequently Asked Questions About Mason Street Grill
What type of cuisine does Mason Street Grill serve?
Mason Street Grill serves classic American grill cuisine, including high-quality wood grilled steaks, sandwiches, and house-made desserts.
What are the regular dinner hours at Mason Street Grill?
Dinner hours are Monday to Saturday from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM, and Sunday from 4:00 PM to 8:00 PM.
When can I enjoy brunch at Mason Street Grill?
Brunch is served on Saturdays and Sundays from 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM; the restaurant is closed for brunch on weekdays.
Does Mason Street Grill offer happy hour? When is it?
Yes, happy hour is Monday through Friday from 4:00 PM to 7:00 PM; it is not offered on weekends.
What pickup and delivery options does Mason Street Grill offer?
They offer in-store pickup and curbside pickup, but do not provide delivery services.
Does Mason Street Grill accept reservations and how can I make one?
Yes, reservations are accepted and can be made through their website or OpenTable reservation link provided.
What beverages and alcohol options are available at Mason Street Grill?
The restaurant serves liquor, beer, wine, and cocktails, and has an onsite bar.
Is Mason Street Grill wheelchair accessible and family friendly?
Yes, the restaurant has wheelchair accessible entrance and high chairs but does not specifically welcome children or have a children's menu.
What are some nearby hotels to Mason Street Grill that I could stay at?
Nearby hotels include The Pfister Hotel with its Grand Ballroom and Pfister Club Lounge, as well as Hotel Metro, Autograph Collection, offering convenient accommodations near Mason Street Grill.
Are there any nearby coffee shops or cafes where I can grab a drink before dining at Mason Street Grill?
Yes, the cafe and coffee shop Phister and The Pfister Hotel also offer great spots to enjoy coffee close to Mason Street Grill.
Where can I find nearby banks or ATMs around Mason Street Grill?
BMO Bank N.A Branches and BMO Harris Bank, which have ATM facilities, are conveniently located near Mason Street Grill for your banking needs.