At Papa Johns Pizza in Menomonee Falls, WI, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Menomonee Falls pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Menomonee Falls or stop by N80W14910 Appleton Avenue for carryout to order the best pizza in Menomonee Falls, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Numerous customers reported extremely long wait times for delivery, with some orders taking over two hours to arrive.
Order Accuracy
Many reviews highlighted frequent mistakes with orders, including missing items and incorrect toppings.
Customer Service
Several customers experienced rude or unhelpful service, with reports of being hung up on or ignored when calling.
Food Quality
There were complaints about the quality of food, including cold pizzas, undercooked items, and issues with cross-contamination.
Staffing Problems
Customers noted that the location appeared understaffed, leading to delays and poor service.
SN
Sean N
Nov 12, 2025
1.0
Tried to order online. Paid. Pizza never showed up after 2 hours. Store won’t answer the phone.
MM
Myster Max
Nov 9, 2025
2.0
Pizza is okay, but it doesn't hit the spot. I only tried it bc they have the 50% off special.
MM
Manny
Nov 1, 2025
1.0
food is passable but service is so bad, always seemingly understaffed and late on orders
JM
Jennifer Marvan
Oct 25, 2025
2.0
This place just needs to close. Everytime i order no matter time of day takes hours to get. No one answers phones. The estimated times are a joke. Dont bother wasting money here
ML
Maggie Langford
Sep 24, 2025
5.0
When I arrived my large pizza and breadstick order was ready. The woman at the register went to grab that, while a gentleman asked if I needed anything else. I asked for plates as I was feeding 10 kids and was immediately given plates and an easy access bunch of napkins. I’m kind of obsessed with how great they are. The napkins. Together they bagged my order and accessories. All the while I am watching as a young man who was clearly already punched out for the day, answered the phone with a smile as another coworker happily but jeeringly rolled her eyes. As if to say, overachiever. Truly a great experience. I have ordered here in the past plenty, but this last week I got a full experience of what is happening there right now. Seemed like a great team. And very well staffed. I’d say I saw at least 8 employees, in the store, working hard on a Friday night at 4:45pm. Not a lot of great service out there these days, and so it was super refreshing.