Rosati's Pizza serves signature Chicago-style pizzas, pastas, wings, salads, and sandwiches that offer high quality, value and flavor. With five generations of experience, every piece of every recipe is original, ensuring Rosati's serves one-of-a-kind dishes from a one-of-a-kind family. As one of the oldest surviving family pizza brands in the U.S., the Rosati name has been firmly established in the city of Chicago and its suburbs. Generations have grown up with the brand and continue to spread it to every corner of the country. Transplanted Chicagoans all over the map have helped bring their favorite pizzeria to 150+ locations across twenty states.
Customers praised the pizza for its taste, especially the deep dish and thin crust options, but some reported issues with incorrect orders and poor ingredient quality.
Service Issues
Numerous reviews highlighted inconsistent service, including rude staff interactions, long wait times, and problems with order accuracy.
Customer Experience
While some customers enjoyed their dining experience and noted friendly staff, others reported feeling neglected or unvalued, particularly when issues arose.
Delivery Problems
Several customers experienced significant delays in delivery, with some orders arriving incorrect or cold, leading to frustration.
Overall Satisfaction
Mixed reviews indicate that while many customers love the pizza, the service and operational issues have led to a decline in overall satisfaction.
TP
Toni Peyton
Nov 13, 2025
3.0
We ordered 3 Gyros and the meat was okay,but the pita bread was very dry and hard to bite into and tasted old. The taziki sauce was nothing more than sourcream mixed with some seasoning or dill. Would not order these again.
RQ
Roxanne Quinlan
Nov 11, 2025
5.0
Was like a taste of home. The way my family had pizza.
CC
Constantin Ciocan
Oct 25, 2025
1.0
Mediocre in all aspects. The worst pizza in Wisconsin. The cheapest ingredients on the market. Overcooked. Tomato paste from can. Disgusting. Horrible.
Do not come here. Never, never, never!
UPDATE: everything is cheap here. If you want to get sick just eat at Risari's. They are a shame for what a pizza makers should be.
Run, run, run.
GW
Graham West
Oct 3, 2025
2.0
Great pizza but terrible consistency with their deep dish. Since pizza extreme closed down in Fitchburg, I have ordered the deep dish here 5 times. 3 of the 5 times I have either received an entirely different deep dish (none of my toppings were on the pizza) OR i am missing a few toppings. Last night I ordered a 10” deep dish with Sausage, pepperoni, onion, green pepper & Jalapeno. I recieved a deep dish with banana peppers instead. I have previously called and have had to wait over two hours to get the correct deep dish sent to my house. I didn’t have the patience to do that last night. It’s a shame they are the only pizza joint close to me that has a really good deep dish. Last night Rosati’s lost my business for good, I’ll stick with frozen deep dish from Lu malnatis or giordano’s.
KG
Kyle Graves
Sep 30, 2025
1.0
Employees arguing and swearing at each other by the counter, messed up my slice order. I ordered two sausages and got one sausage and one cheese. I tried to correct lady at register and she got snippy and said cheese was for another customer and grabbed my two boxes. I should have double checked but wanted to get out of there as quick as possible. Definitely will never go back.
What type of cuisine is served at Rosati's Pizza in Madison?
Rosati's Pizza serves signature Chicago-style pizzas, pastas, wings, salads, and sandwiches with original recipes from a multi-generational family legacy.
What are the opening hours of Rosati's Pizza on weekdays?
From Monday to Wednesday, Rosati's Pizza is open from 10:30 AM to 11:00 PM and on Thursday and Friday it is open from 10:30 AM until midnight.
Does Rosati's Pizza offer takeout or delivery services?
Yes, Rosati's Pizza offers takeout, delivery, and catering services.
Is Rosati's Pizza wheelchair accessible?
Yes, Rosati's Pizza has a wheelchair-accessible entrance.
Are families and children welcome at Rosati's Pizza?
Yes, Rosati's Pizza welcomes families and children.
What payment methods does Rosati's Pizza accept?
Rosati's Pizza requires cash payment only.
Where is Rosati's Pizza located?
Rosati's Pizza is located at 6644 Mineral Point Road, Madison, WI 53705, United States.
Are there nearby places where I can withdraw Bitcoin or cash near Rosati's Pizza?
Yes, the CoinFlip Bitcoin ATM at Paradise Plus is nearby, useful for Bitcoin transactions and cash withdrawals.
What nearby dining options are close to Rosati's Pizza for more food variety?
Nearby options include Qdoba Mexican Grill, China Kitchen, SUBWAY, Sake Sushi, Ginza Japanese Restaurant, and Szechuan Garden.
What fitness or wellness facilities are near Rosati's Pizza for combining a workout with a meal?
Nearby fitness options include Jazzercise Madison, Madison Jazzercise, 9Round Madison West, and 9Round Kickboxing Fitness - Madison West; wellness options like Dahl Family Chiropractic are also close by.