Domino's Pizza

3.2
275 reviews

About

Pizza RestaurantRestaurant Delivery ServiceTake Out RestaurantFast Food RestaurantDomino's Pizza
Looking for great pizza in Madison? At Domino’s, we’re passionate about bringing you the best pizza experience, whether you're carrying out or ordering pizza delivery. Whether you’re craving thin, foldable New York Style pizza or a thick, Handmade Pan pizza, Domino’s has you covered. Or try our delicious, cheesy Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza today! We offer more than just mouthwatering pizza—dishes like our fan-favorite mac and cheese, salads, pasta, and chicken wings will satisfy all your needs. We’ll give you great value with our unbeatable deals, making it easy to enjoy more for less. Wherever you are, the Domino's pizza near you is here to satisfy your cravings with taste and quality. Order from 4680 Cottage Grove Road .

Location

Domino's Pizza
4680 Cottage Grove Road, Madison, WI
53716, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.2
275 reviews
5 stars
109
4 stars
35
3 stars
21
2 stars
17
1 star
93

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Order Accuracy

Numerous customers reported issues with incorrect orders and missing items, leading to dissatisfaction.

Customer Service

Feedback highlighted poor customer service experiences, including rude management and unresponsive staff.

Delivery Issues

Many reviews mentioned extremely long delivery times, with some orders taking over two hours to arrive.

Food Quality

Several customers expressed disappointment with the quality of food, citing cold or poorly made items.

Staffing Problems

Reviews indicated that the location is often understaffed, contributing to delays and mistakes.
  • KK
    Kale
    Jan 1, 2026
    1.0
    i don't usually post negative reviews but i'm hoping upper management might see this. i've had decent experiences at this location thus far but tonight i submitted an order for 7:30. it's 10pm now and i never received my food even after calling to ask about the status. this store is severely understaffed and i sympathize. i probably won't be back as i'd rather not be out of my money again.
  • ND
    nadjet derkaoui
    Jan 1, 2026
    1.0
    I had a terrible experience with this Domino’s. I placed a delivery order and never received it. I tried calling the store multiple times and no one answered the phone. Because of that, I went to the store myself to pick up the order, only to be treated very poorly. The staff were rude, ignored me, and didn’t listen when I tried to explain the situation. There was no apology, no effort to help, and no customer service at all. This was extremely frustrating and disappointing. I will not be ordering from this location again. Also the charge for the delivery and tip were transacted. When I asked for a refund since I picked up my order myself, the lady ignored me and walked out.
  • AF
    Adrian Farrow
    Dec 28, 2025
    1.0
    Terrible Management – Avoid This Location Order #660611 (12/28/25) from the Cottage Grove Rd Domino’s was made incorrectly. The order clearly stated pepperoni on ONE SIDE ONLY, NO sausage. The pizza was wrong. When I called, the manager was rude and dismissive, said he would remake it, then later claimed I ordered it wrong and said he was doing nothing. After that, the store stopped answering the phone entirely. We were left at home with kids waiting for food, and I had to call another Domino’s location just to get help. The manager also refused to give his name or any contact info. This isn’t a simple mistake — it’s a management failure. Avoid this location.
  • DA
    Dj Antoniewicz
    Dec 14, 2025
    3.0
    Come here all the time since its right down the street. Past three times we've ordered the bacon stuffed cheesy bread with no jalepenos and they put EXTRA jalepenos. These times I've also noticed there's only one employee in the store which is not only dangerous but causes more room for mistakes. And each time that employee is understandably unpleasant. They also no longer cut all the way through the bread or pizza so we had to recut it at home. Don't know why the past year this location seemed to just loose its give a damn but it is sad to see and hope it gets corrected sometime soon otherwise Pizza Hut is literally across the parking lot
  • BA
    Bryan Ahrens
    Dec 7, 2025
    1.0
    Unfortunately this location has really gone downhill this year. Delivery used to be timely and delicious. We’ve now had 2 or 3 experiences of extremely long wait times. Tonight’s was 2 hours 40 min. On top of long waits, bad customer service. Called to check state as online tracker showed “quality check” for 45 minutes. No answer on the first try. Called again, was then told on their end the system showed out for delivery. I asked if they could have driver contact with update? Employee then consulted manager to ask - I hear him in the background state my order was on standby for pickup from a driver and was next in line. The employee gets back on the line and says the driver will contact me? I asked about the managers comment, confirming that my order had in fact been sitting for the past 45 minutes. After a long pause she said “I guess” to which I asked so you’re providing me false updates then? She HUNG UP! Obviously receiving an order within the hour is ideal but I would have understood a busy Sunday night. I called back, the manager answered, informed him the woman not only lied to me but hung up on me and I really didn’t appreciate that. He was kind and apologetic and provided a truthful update. Still look an additional hour and 40 min to receive the order. Cold, not fresh, unappetizing. Majorly disappointing service - when did that become normal?

Frequently Asked Questions About Domino's Pizza

What types of pizza does Domino's Pizza in Madison offer?

Domino's offers Specialty Pizzas and also lets you build your own pizza using New York Style, Handmade Pan, or Parmesan Stuffed Crust options.

What are the operating hours for takeout and delivery at Domino's Pizza located at 4680 Cottage Grove Road?

Domino's Pizza is open daily from 10:30 AM to midnight, except on Fridays and Saturdays when it stays open until 1:00 AM for both takeout and delivery.