Every cafe is an experience. We try to incorporate pre-existing architecture and history into every cafe—repurposing as much as we can. Yet, despite their individuality, all our cafes share a familiar and inviting ambience. Come unwind; enjoy some coffee and good eats.
Customers frequently praised the coffee for its bold flavors and quality, with many considering it the best in Madison.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted inconsistent service, including long wait times and mistakes with orders, leading to customer frustration.
Food Quality
While some enjoyed the food offerings, others reported disappointment with the quality and portion sizes, particularly for breakfast items.
Atmosphere
The cafe's atmosphere was generally well-received, with many appreciating the decor and seating options, though some noted it could be noisy.
Pricing Concerns
Customers expressed concerns about rising prices relative to portion sizes and quality, making it harder to justify dining here.
HK
Hilja Koski
4 days ago
5.0
What a stunning spot. Got here as soon as they opened. Lots of seating. Caramel Apple matcha (hot) and avocado toast with fried egg (the bread is ridiculous, the peppers on top really sent it up a notch and the fried egg for more protein!). Delightful.
SB
Sofia Baucis
5 days ago
5.0
One of the nicest coffee spots in Madison. Decent coffee, good flavours and food. Service is nice, but the ambiance is what gets me. Pretty nice to get a warm or cold beverage at a cozy place, and do some work while enjoying nice music.
CP
Chris “Cj” P
Nov 9, 2025
4.0
Very well done 👍.
All of it.
(Packed on Saturday mornings 😄)
KW
Kyla Wenger
Oct 26, 2025
5.0
Some of the best drinks around! Seriously love the smoked vanilla mocha, it may be my all time favorite drink. Fun decor in the shop too, friendly staff, and fairly quick despite a long line on a busy Saturday.
GR
Greg Robbins
Oct 25, 2025
2.0
Ordered two drinks that came out 15 minutes apart from each other. When the baristas were asked where the second drink was, they were not interested in helping me get the second drink.
Frequently Asked Questions About Colectivo Coffee On the Square
What is the address of Colectivo Coffee On the Square?
Colectivo Coffee On the Square is located at 25 S Pinckney Street, Madison, WI 53703, US.
What are the regular opening hours of Colectivo Coffee On the Square?
Colectivo Coffee On the Square is open every day from 6:30 AM to 6:00 PM.
What kind of experience does Colectivo Coffee On the Square offer to its customers?
The cafe offers an experience that incorporates pre-existing architecture and history, creating a familiar and inviting ambience where you can unwind with coffee and good eats.
What is the best way to contact Colectivo Coffee On the Square by phone?
You can reach Colectivo Coffee On the Square at +1 608-255-0474.
Does Colectivo Coffee On the Square have an online presence where I can learn more?
Yes, you can visit their website at https://colectivo.com/pages/on-the-square or check their Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/192966334213146.
Are there other coffee shops near Colectivo Coffee On the Square?
Yes, there is another Colectivo Coffee nearby, as well as Todofresco, which is a cafe and smoothie juice bar located close by.
Which restaurants are located near Colectivo Coffee On the Square for dining options?
Nearby restaurants include Tipsy Cow, Graze, L'Etoile Restaurant, Snakehole Lounge, and Maduro, offering a variety of dining experiences after your visit.
What nearby places can help me navigate to Colectivo Coffee On the Square?
Nearby landmarks include the Clerk of the Wisconsin Supreme Court & Court of Appeals and the Tenney Plaza Ramp parking area, which can help you find your way to the cafe.
Is there a place to park near Colectivo Coffee On the Square?
Yes, the Tenney Plaza Ramp parking facility is located nearby for convenient parking.
What other services and amenities are close to Colectivo Coffee On the Square that visitors might find useful?
Nearby services include legal services by Christopher T. Van Wagner, community services and printing by Wcris, and men's and women's clothing at Lucca Fine Men's Clothing.