About
RestaurantBar
MJ's Supper Club Serves Some of the Best Steaks, Seafood, Soup & Salad Bar & Great Cocktails in a Very Warm & Cozy Atmosphere on Rustic Road MM in Hortonville, WI.
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- DeliveryNot available
- TakeoutAvailable
- Accepts reservationsAvailable
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.5
344 reviews
5 stars
238
4 stars
67
3 stars
19
2 stars
6
1 star
14
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Mixed reviews on food quality, with some praising the prime rib and potato cakes, while others reported dry or bland dishes.
Service
Service experiences varied; many customers highlighted friendly and attentive staff, but some reported long waits and inattentive service.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere is generally described as cozy and welcoming, with a traditional supper club vibe, though some noted it can be crowded.
Pricing
Several customers mentioned that prices are on the higher side, leading to mixed feelings about value for money.
- EBEllen BreithauptJan 3, 20265.0Just had another excellent dinner at MJ’s Supper Club. The garlic Parmesan salmon and potato patties were delicious! Service was cheerful, prompt & professional throughout our meal. We felt very welcome, & will definitely be back!
- PTP THUMANNDec 23, 20254.0Dining alone, nice place.
- RGRoss GerdesDec 13, 20255.0Small hidden gem outside of Hortonville, WI, this supper clubs appears to be a home nestled in the woods with a pole barn bar behind it, but what's inside is a beautiful example of a traditional Wisconsin Supper Club. We were waited on by an amazing bartender that made my guest some amazing drinks, including her signature Salted Caramel martinin, which did not disappoint, and she was welcoming and made sure we had what we needed, even though the place was packed and she was very busy. Our server greeted us, took out order and let us know our table number and to help ourselves to the soup and salad bar. The salad bar was small yet packed with fresh ingredients one would expect at a Supper Club, the amazing prime rib soup was robust and warmed my tummy on a cold winters night. My guest ordered the tenderloin while I got the king cut prime rib, al Oscar, with the signature potato cakes. Hands down the best in the area. Warm yellow hollandise and the lumped crab with asparagus flowed over my generous portion of prime rib. My guests tenderloin was so good, she doesn't want to eat it anywhere else. Our server was amazing and we had plenty for leftovers to savor the taste again tomorrow. A+++++
- JSJohn SchroederSep 28, 20255.0Great
- SBSpencer BlackAug 9, 20251.0Food was good but we were very disappointed to see the disrespect shown to Wisconsin soldiers who died while serving our nation
Frequently Asked Questions About MJ's Supper Club
What are the operating hours of MJ's Supper Club?
MJ's Supper Club is open Wednesday and Thursday from 4 PM to 8 PM, and Friday and Saturday from 4 PM to 9 PM. It is closed on Monday, Tuesday, and Sunday.
Does MJ's Supper Club offer any pickup or delivery services?
MJ's Supper Club offers in-store pickup but does not provide delivery services.
What types of food and specialties does MJ's Supper Club serve?
MJ's Supper Club specializes in steak and seafood, featuring dishes like Tenderloin Oscar, along with cocktails, soup and salad bar, sandwiches, and hamburgers.
Are reservations required or accepted at MJ's Supper Club?
Reservations are accepted at MJ's Supper Club, but they are not required.
What payment methods are accepted at MJ's Supper Club?
MJ's Supper Club accepts American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Does MJ's Supper Club provide a bar and serve alcoholic beverages?
Yes, MJ's Supper Club has an onsite bar and serves cocktails, beer, and wine.
Is MJ's Supper Club family-friendly and accessible?
Yes, MJ's Supper Club welcomes families and children, has a children's menu, high chairs, and a wheelchair accessible entrance.
Can customers enjoy live music or happy hour at MJ's Supper Club?
MJ's Supper Club serves happy hour food but does not have live music.
What nearby places can I visit around MJ's Supper Club?
Nearby you can visit The Country Club, a steakhouse, and Hills of Hackberry, which includes a concert venue and real estate services. These are great options to explore before or after dining at MJ's Supper Club.
How can nearby places like The Country Club and Hills of Hackberry help when visiting MJ's Supper Club?
If you're visiting MJ's Supper Club, you can easily combine your trip with a meal at The Country Club steakhouse or check out events at Hills of Hackberry concert venue nearby, enhancing your local experience.