Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• BC

  Biblical Creation

  Dec 2, 2025
  4.0
  Good deals on pizza this night. 50% off. Pizza is good, but I like domino's better
• PW

  Phillip W

  Apr 4, 2025
  1.0
  Spent over half an hour waiting for a carryout order after the pickup time. Half the food was cold despite waiting so long. No restitution was given for the extremely long wait past the pickup time.
• GL

  Gloria Lorraine

  Apr 6, 2024
  1.0
  Whole family got sick within hours of eating. It appears this location is not practicing proper food handling.
• JF

  Jason Frausto

  Mar 21, 2024
  1.0
  Ordered one large pepperoni and pineapple pizza. When we arrived to pick it up the manager said we upgraded you to stuffed crust at no extra charge. Unfortunately, that’s not what we ordered, or were in the mood to eat. Instead of apologizing the guy who did this and the cashier were both rude and unapologetic. He was upset he would have to make us the pizza we ordered through their app. So we sat there for another 15 minutes while he made us what we originally ordered. Zero offer of a refund, no apology, nothing. We will never come back here and I suggest you do the same. We’ve had zero issues at dominos in Oconomowoc. Whoever owns this location….good luck.
• DW

  Dan W

  Feb 15, 2024
  1.0
  One of the weirdest and worst pizza delivery experiences I've ever had. We called for pickup and the employees said it would be faster to have the pizza delivered,which makes no sense, but we reluctantly agreed. After an hour and a half of waiting we called back and the employee said that they gave our pizzas to a Door Dash driver to deliver because they didn't have drivers (why would they suggest delivery then?). We asked where the pizza could be and they said they don't have any info about the Door Dash drivers. Not only did we not want to order delivery in the first place, they also stated over the phone that it would be faster to have it delivered, and on top of that they gave it to an outside source to deliver and they DID NOT deliver anything at all. The Driver either delivered the pizza to a random house and took no payment, took the pizza for themselves, or the employees didn't make our pizza at all and just came up with that story to cover for it. (Why would they give door dash a pizza to deliver when we haven't even paid yet? Is the Door Dash driver who doesn't work for Papa Johns supposed to bring the cash back to the store for them? I doubt it) Do not order delivery from this location, you might as well drive out to the next nearest Papa Johns, it would be much faster.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza