Fresh Thyme Market

4.3
1156 reviews

About

Grocery StoreDeliBakerySupermarketButcher ShopProduce MarketHealth Food StoreVitamin & Supplements Store
Fresh Thyme Market is a grocery store and natural food marketplace in Greenfield, WI that provides healthy food and healthy values, with an atmosphere reminiscent of your local farmers market. We are committed to offering a variety of Clean Label products, free from artificial colors, flavors or preservatives, as well as many organic options. We carry many items catering to those following vegan, paleo, keto, vegetarian or wheat- and gluten-free diets, as well as anyone on a journey towards healthier, more delicious living.

Details

  • DeliveryAvailable
  • Credit cardAvailable
  • DebitAvailable
  • Mobile paymentsAvailable

Location

Fresh Thyme Market
8680 West Sura Lane, Greenfield, WI
53228, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.3
1,156 reviews
5 stars
701
4 stars
276
3 stars
94
2 stars
42
1 star
43

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Customer Service

Feedback on staff interactions is mixed, with some praising friendly and helpful employees, while others report rude and unprofessional behavior.

Pricing

Many customers find the prices to be high, with some stating that they can find better deals elsewhere.

Product Selection

The store offers a good variety of fresh produce and specialty items, but some customers express disappointment in the availability of certain products.

Store Cleanliness

The store is generally noted for being clean and well-organized, contributing positively to the shopping experience.
  • AM
    Andrew Mersch
    Jan 4, 2026
    5.0
    Always easy going
  • YH
    Yingdi Han
    Dec 17, 2025
    4.0
    Really nice store with the friendliest, most welcoming staff, but it is now officially unaffordable. Of course, it has always been on the pricier side, but since my last visit 6 months ago it has gone up substantially for just about everything, so much so that no one with even average income can visit.
  • CB
    Carson Bragg
    Dec 7, 2025
    4.0
    Overall, a pretty good store overall with a decent selection of healthier options, but the prices are a bit expensive. I'm a little disappointed that they don't have more zero or low-waste products, and the products they did have in stock are starting to phase out on discontinued clearance. Also, for a natural foods store, there aren't as many gluten-free options as you'd think. Otherwise, if you don't have a lot of dietary restrictions, it's a better selection.
  • JJ
    Janet
    Dec 6, 2025
    1.0
    Would give it -0 stars if I could! I recently visited Fresh Thyme after seeing online that Mountain Valley Spring Water was “ready for pickup.” I chose not to pay the $5 fee just to reserve the order, since most stores (Walmart/Big chains) dont charge for that. When I arrived the entire experience went downhill fast. It was incredibly hard to find anyone willing to help. The shelf was empty even though the website said the waters were available. When I finally found a worker, she was kind enough to look into it and brought out another employee. This bald white man who I assume was a Manager. (Very unprofessional, very rude, super racist) The moment he showed up, he didn’t talk to me. He yelled! Out of nowhere.. “YEAH NO! WE DON’T HAVE 12 PACKS YET! I MEAN WE DO BUT WE DON’T! IF YOU WANT GET 12 INDIVIDUALLY WE DONT HAVE BOXES!” The way he spoke to me was so aggressive, so unnecessary and so disrespectful that I literally blanked out. My partner had to repeat what he said because I was so shocked and angry. It felt targeted. It felt personal. It felt like I wasn’t welcome there at all. Like i bothered him to do some actual work smh. At self checkout, the woman assisting was rude as well. A bottle wouldn’t scan and she took her time barely acknowledging us. Meanwhile, I watched other customers (white customers) get greeted, helped, and spoken to politely. We didn’t get a “hello” we didn’t get a “have a good day” NOTHING. I can only speak from my own experience, but as a Brown shopper I left feeling completely unwelcome and singled out. It honestly felt like a place where people who look like me aren’t treated the same. I will never shop here again. And based on how I was treated, if you’re Brown or Black I would personally avoid this store! No one deserves to be made to feel the way I did over something as simple as trying to buy water. smh..
  • LM
    Lynda Mylos
    Nov 8, 2025
    5.0
    Good selection of plant based items!