Rosati's Pizza

Reviews

• JP

  James Peck

  Feb 10, 2026
  1.0
  A horrible experience ordering online. I gave them my all the information including my credit card number and then there was no confirmation my order was placed. And, guess what? Their phone number doesn’t work. Guess I’ll try somewhere else. I’ll never try ordering here again.
• AR

  Arthur Rapkin

  Jan 10, 2026
  1.0
  I have been a customer of Rosati‘s for over 25 years. I don’t know, but I suspect that Rosati‘s was bought out. The new owner/Management has changed the pizza recipe and ingredients dramatically and has now reduced it to less than a cheap frozen store bought product which you could buy in the grocery store for between six and $10 the pizza that I ordered was a 12 inch pepperoni pizza. I didn’t see any pepperoni on the pizza and when I called to ask about why I received a cheese pizza when I ordered a pepperoni pizza I was told that I And under it would be the pepperoni. I actually did that and found out that they used about 1/3 the amount of pepperoni that any pizza would’ve had on it. The amount of cheese that was on the pizza was about half of the amount of cheese on any pizza That you could find that would have pepperoni buried underneath a thin layer of cheese. Pepperoni pizza is always and I mean always have pictures of the pizza and you can see the pepperoni not these pizzas. Stay away from wasting your money. I spent over $23. On this crappy cheap pizza
• MM

  Michael Medrano

  Jan 5, 2026
  5.0
  My first time,I ordered the Chicago style deep dish as well as a veggie pizza. They were extremely good will definitely be ordering again
• CN

  Carla Nichols

  Dec 17, 2025
  1.0
  This was my 2nd or 3rd time placing a delivery order from the Fox Point location. So so disappointed in the service. It took over an hr for delivery each time. I placed the order at 504pm. After 50 minutes,I called them 5 times to get an update and couldn't get anyone on the phone, no matter what number I pushed. They call me at 622pm telling me my pizza will be ready shortly. I requested to cncl the order and told the man I was going to write a review. Very nonchalantly he says "ok." Apparently he didnt care about the $96.75 pizza order. I will NOT order from that location again. I called Menomonee Falls. They answered quickly, and took my order. I had my pizza in 30 minutes or so.
• CA

  Christopher August

  Dec 15, 2025
  5.0
  Probably the best carry out pizza available in the North Shore. Still a chain, but a step up from Papa John's and Dominos. Their marinara dipping sauce is unreal!

Frequently Asked Questions About Rosati's Pizza