Domino's Pizza

Reviews

• AO

  Ally Olsen

  3 days ago
  1.0
  Employee’s were so rude to me last night. They didn’t greet me when I came through the door and had me waiting at the counter for 10 minutes.
• ML

  Matthew Lee

  Feb 6, 2026
  2.0
  Last 2 orders..... 1 I asked for light sauce, still got regular sauce. The other I asked for no garlic crust. Still got garlic crust. And tonight I had my order cancelled because "our driver has 4 deliveries and thats too many" and proceeded to hang up on me🤦‍♂️. if 4 deliveries is overwhelming, I'd hate to see how the staff respond to an actual busy store. Seems to me, Dominos Fort Atkinson has gotten comfortable with mediocre performance.
• UH

  Uski House

  Feb 4, 2026
  5.0
  I want to specifically highlight Sam, the manager, because the difference when he’s running the store is night and day. When Sam is on shift, orders are accurate, food is hot and fresh, and the whole place just runs smoothly. You can tell he takes real pride in what he does and holds the team to a high standard — not in a harsh way, but in a way that keeps everything moving and customers taken care of. Any negative reviews you see honestly don’t line up with my experiences at all, and it’s pretty clear those orders must have happened when Sam wasn’t there. Every time I’ve ordered while he was managing, the service has been fast, friendly, and consistent. That kind of reliability doesn’t happen by accident — it comes from strong leadership. Sam is the kind of manager every location should want: professional, attentive, and clearly invested in both the customers and the staff. If ownership is reading this, you’ve got someone special here. He’s doing things the right way, and it shows every single time he’s on the floor.
• JJ

  James

  Feb 1, 2026
  2.0
  These people are so shady with the toppings even when you pay extra. Do yourself a favor and just get a pothole from quick trip and it's better pizza
• NW

  Nicholas J Wetzel

  Jan 4, 2026
  1.0
  My girlfriend and I order from this dominoes about twice a month. I use to get the chicken wings almost everytime we ordered. Atleast a 8 piece. But I stopped, reason why? Well the last I new when you order CHICKEN WINGS you expect chicken wings right? Well when you order a 8 piece wing and you get 5-7 drum sticks, I dont think that counts as chicken wings anymore. Also, if I may ask, at what point are they not considered chicken wings anymore, and since when did wings transform into drummies? Isnt that 2 differet parts of the bird? I ordered a 8 piece chicken wing tonight and got 1 wing! Un fricken real that this is even allowed. Shouldn't this be considered to a degree false advertisement? I mean c'mon! This is exactly why I dont waiste my $10 bucks anymore. Such a disappointment. I'll stick to my routine and go to the bar on Thursday for actual chicken wings.

Frequently Asked Questions About Domino's Pizza