Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• MK

  Macenzi Knaus

  Nov 15, 2025
  1.0
  They where very rude I spent 75$ only 3 pizzas 2 sodas not a very big deal right but then they called and demanded a tip because it was a 75$ order. if anything they should be paying me for spending soooo much on so little of food talk about not good workers
• KK

  Kidane Kelati

  Nov 4, 2025
  1.0
  They are very disrespectful i was ordered and when I called them after 1&30 they said we can not deliver they are disrespectful
• SN

  Sara Niederfeld

  Oct 18, 2025
  1.0
  Ordered dinner, they use a third party delivery system apparently (DoorDash). Looked at the tracking info, and it started that it was delivered so checked to see if they just set it by the door. Alas no food, so obviously the driver stole it at this point. Call the store to get it dealt with so the children get their dinner. They state they have to call and deal with DoorDash. Call back 20 minutes later, the manager attempted contacting dd they didn't respond. He refused to make the order until dd agreed the driver stole it. Asked to have our food made while this was happening, and got shut down and told that can't be done. Asked for a refund and to cancel the order and the manager gave so much attitude and disrespect. This is ridiculous. I will never patronize your business again.
• SB

  Scott Behrmann

  Aug 27, 2025
  1.0
  AVOID THIS LOCATION!! My wife and I were in Green Bay looking at properties and had to be in Appleton by 8:30, so we decided to grab Papa Johns (usually decent corporate pizza). At 7:41, I placed an order with an ETA of completion between 7:51 and 8:01. I arrived at the location around 8 PM to discover the store clouded with smoke. I do not believe that the oven was properly working. I told the manager that I had an online order. He looked it up (I could tell at this time that they had not even started preparing it) and said that it would be another 10 minutes due to me ordering wings well done. I told him that I did not have time to wait 10 and just to prepare them normally which he said would take 5 minutes. I went next door to the wine store for about 5 minutes and returned to the store. Another employee came to me after several minutes and I let her know that I was waiting on an order. 5 minutes passed and I had still not been served. I spoke out to the manager who appeared to be ignoring me, and asked where my order was. He started getting argumentative with me and said that it had not even been 30 min. About 5 minutes later, I received my order and it was horrible! I had ordered a NY style crust pizza with Canadian bacon & pineapple and 6 wings. The crust was flavorless and definitely not NY style, very light on the toppings, and poorly cut. The wings were over-sauced and mushy. I will never order from this location again!! TODAY BETWEEN 7:51 PM - 8:01 PM

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza