Jimmy John's

Reviews

• SW

  Scott Wales

  Nov 6, 2025
  5.0
  Only place to get a lettuce wrap un-wich that's keto.
• JM

  Jessica Miller

  Sep 19, 2025
  1.0
  I couldn't take a picture because it was too gross to share, but there was like 4 black, curly hairs in my sub.. I don't know if I ate anymore, but I was so grossed out, I almost threw up. Also, I ordered it with the french onions on it, and it was loaded, too full with them, along with the horseradish sauce I added. I don't think I will be going back there anytime soon, and this was actually my 2nd visit this week alone. Kind of a regular there. I will go elsewhere from now on. Disgusted with the sub, and I think I made someone pissed by adding those extras to the sub. It actually was ruined.
• BB

  Becky Blessinger

  Aug 5, 2025
  1.0
  I ordered delivery from Jimmy John's in Baraboo and wanted it delivered to the hotel. It wasn't delivered to my door. I heard the delivery driver was eating my meal when I called to question them about it. This is unacceptable! I won't go here or ask for a delivery ever again.
• KW

  Kyle Weis

  Jul 15, 2025
  4.0
  Great sandwiches, of course. Loses 1 star because of a small gripe: My pickle is never cut the way I want it. Also, most times I get carry out, so the cleanliness of the store is a non-issue, but it is often a little dirty (just like, leftover crumbs on tables, nothing obscene).