Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton

4.2
1004 reviews

About

Pizza RestaurantRestaurant Delivery ServiceCatererGlass Nickel Pizza
An Appleton favorite for pizza serving unique, award winning pies with renowned salads, subs, homemade lasagna, pasta and more. Offering delivery, carryout, catering and dine-in with full bar and expansive patio seating weather permitting (hey, this is Wisconsin!). Dedicated to local ingredients, sustainable practices and community service. Join us for Glass Nickel Pizza. In Pizza We Trust®!

Details

  • Dine-inAvailable
  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Accepts reservationsNot available

Location

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton
2120 West College Ave, Appleton, WI
54914, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.2
1,004 reviews
5 stars
598
4 stars
210
3 stars
78
2 stars
36
1 star
82

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Many customers praised the pizza for being delicious, with some noting specific favorites and good flavor.

Service Issues

Several reviews highlighted inconsistent service, with complaints about slow wait times, incorrect orders, and unhelpful staff.

Delivery Problems

Customers reported issues with delivery, including late arrivals, incorrect orders, and cold food.

Atmosphere

While some enjoyed the atmosphere, others found it lacking or noted cleanliness issues.

Value for Money

Some customers felt that prices were high relative to portion sizes or quality, particularly with salads and certain menu items.
  • KP
    Kari P
    6 days ago
    5.0
    To level set I have frequented the Madison Atwood location many times previously. The amount of love I have for this place is priceless. This was my first visit to this location and it did not disappoint! The menu is extensive with chooses for most all diet needs. This visit I modified a salad to be vegan and the spinach cheese bread as well. Absolutely fantastic! Large portions, delicious, fresh, and reasonable prices. The service was great and very professional. If you haven’t been I highly suggest you visit! Order takeout or delivery, or dine in and enjoy the beautiful building and full bar. It’s not only a win but a home run!
  • CR
    Candi Rivas
    Dec 14, 2025
    5.0
    Yummy calzone! I ordered the side salad it was very fresh and yummy too. I am from california and thought i would try it via doordash but the restaurant delivers your order directly to you without using doordash. The guy that delivered it was very, very nice, and gave me a good tip on how to order if I wanted to in the future. I'm only here 2 days, so unfortunately, I won't be able to but I just wanted the locals to know.It is a very good place and the service is great
  • DK
    Dan Kelly
    Dec 8, 2025
    4.0
    Good pizza at a decent price. My fav is the chicky, chicky, parm, Parm!
  • WC
    William A Custer
    Dec 5, 2025
    4.0
    Food was pretty good and service was great!
  • KB
    Ken Bennett
    Nov 22, 2025
    5.0
    I placed a delivery order. Its my favorite go to pizza when I visit Appleton!

Frequently Asked Questions About Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton

What are the dine-in hours for Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton?

Dine-in is available daily from 11:00 AM to 8:30 PM.

When is Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton open during the week?

Open Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM.