Customers frequently reported slow service, long wait times for food, and poor handling of takeout orders.
Food Quality
Many reviews mentioned declining food quality, particularly with wings being overcooked, small, or lacking sauce.
Staff Performance
While some staff members received praise for their attentiveness and friendliness, others were described as rude or apathetic.
Inconsistent Experience
Diners noted a disparity between dining in and takeout experiences, with takeout often being cold or incorrect.
SG
Sabrina Greene
2 days ago
1.0
Absolute worst experience here. I understand the Packers are playing and it’s the playoffs but they definitely need to work on there carry out timing. Simply don’t say the order will be ready in 30 minutes and we have to wait there for over an hour for our order. I’m not even sure that was the main issue though because we were asked our name again and then they find the order and the food isn’t even luke warm it’s straight up cold. So now, do we not only have to reheat the food when we got home and are we’re missing wings and there’s hardly any sauce on them. They all need to be more vocal when calling out orders ESPECIALLY during a Packer game when the atmosphere is expected to be loud. We noticed many people cancelling orders but we decided to give a chance. Simply just do better.
HK
Holly Krabbe
Dec 23, 2025
1.0
I have dined in and ordered takeout many times.
Takeout is always ready significantly late. It's sometimes ready more than 20 minutes after they say it will be ready.
A few staff members have been rude (mostly they're very nice, but there are some VERY rude waitresses).
The wings are not nearly as big as they used to be - they're tiny! They used to give you two small wings and counted it as one, but now I get wings the size of a quarter and that counts as one whole wing.
Starting to not be worth the cost! And this specific location should work on their carryout time!!
JD
Julie Debehnke
Dec 17, 2025
1.0
I've ordered delivery from this location many times and every single time something is wrong with my order. Missing drinks, missing food, wrong sauces... I will never order from this establishment again.
YT
Yoda Koj Txiv
Dec 16, 2025
1.0
What happened to the good-sized wings? I haven’t eaten here since 2023, and the wings have definitely gotten smaller. If you’re looking for bigger wings, I’d recommend going to Wingstop instead.
KC
Kyle Casey
Nov 29, 2025
5.0
Sat in the bar area and at first we were unsure of how the service was going to be. The person that came to the table was from behind the bar(bartender) and seemed kinda spacey. Man were we wrong.... after we ordered our drinks and watching him make a mojito, and the small talk he had about different items on the menu before we ordered we knew we were in for great service.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Appleton serve?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Appleton serves award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with a choice of 26 sauces and seasonings.
What are the operating hours of Buffalo Wild Wings on weekdays?
From Monday to Wednesday, Buffalo Wild Wings is open from 11:00 AM to midnight; on Thursday and Friday, it stays open until 1:00 AM.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings in Appleton offer takeout services?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings is categorized as a takeout restaurant in addition to being a sports bar and chicken wings restaurant.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Appleton?
It is located at 3201 E Calumet Street, Appleton, WI 54915, USA.
What is the contact phone number for Buffalo Wild Wings in Appleton?
The main phone number is +1 920-733-9464.
Can I visit nearby places like Massage Envy or US Bank before or after dining at Buffalo Wild Wings?
Yes, Massage Envy - Calumet and US Bank are nearby, making it convenient to combine your visit to Buffalo Wild Wings with a massage session or banking needs.
Are there other dining options near Buffalo Wild Wings in Appleton?
Nearby dining options include Tropical Smoothie Cafe, Tom's Drive In, and Nick-n-Willy's Pizza, ideal for exploring different cuisines before or after your visit.
How can I access Buffalo Wild Wings using nearby transit or landmarks?
The location near notable businesses like US Bank and Advance Auto Parts can help you easily find Buffalo Wild Wings on E Calumet Street in Appleton.
Are there any places nearby Buffalo Wild Wings for post-meal relaxation or beauty treatments?
Yes, CiCi Nails & Spa and Cost Cutters are close by, providing opportunities for beauty and spa treatments after your meal.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings have a social media presence where I can check updates or promotions?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings has an official Facebook page available for updates at https://www.facebook.com/333135143422398.