Numero Uno Pizza

Reviews

• JW

  Jon Went

  3 days ago
  5.0
  The staff are friendly, and they always have a diverse array of pizza to choose from. Being vegetarian they almost always have a few nonmeat options. It is a small business so it is a delight to know such a business like this exists that I can stop in for a slice or order from a vast selection as well. They also have desserts bakala amd chocolate on hand. Excellent in every way!
• BE

  Benjamin Engelman

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Amazing! Went here super late on a Tuesday night with friends, and the owner was so nice. The three of us were blown away by the pizza, ESPECIALLY THE CRUST!!!!!! Best crust I’ve ever had. Thank you Numero Uno Pizza!
• GM

  Gabrielle Mathison

  Jan 4, 2026
  5.0
  The pizza here is a hidden gem! You can get to-go slices or a whole pie. So yummy and the service is great every time. Great for big parties inside or if you just wanna stop and grab a slice to eat! Also has a bunch of canned drinks and dessert too!
• EF

  Eli Farr

  Jan 4, 2026
  5.0
  Stopped into Umero Uno on a walk-in craving pizza, and they absolutely delivered. First off, the customer service was top-notch from the moment I walked in—friendly, welcoming, and genuinely willing to help. I had a pretty unique, off-menu pizza idea, and instead of brushing it off, they jumped in with suggestions, asked the right questions, and made it happen without any hassle. That kind of attitude is rare and really appreciated. And the pizza? Fantastic. The crust was cooked perfectly, the toppings were fresh, and everything tasted balanced and intentional—not just thrown together. Even with a custom order, they nailed it like it was one of their regular specialties. If you want great pizza and a team that treats you like they actually care—especially if you’re the kind of person who likes to customize—Umero Uno is the spot. Highly recommend.
• JA

  Joseph Alaimo

  Dec 25, 2025
  5.0
  Great spot for delicious pizza. I like that you can order several different styles of pizza by the slice, my favorite being the beef blue cheese. It's a very satisfying slice of pizza. The staff are inviting and the atmosphere warm, with ample seating inside. A gem of a pizza parlor. Also nice that they stay open until 11 pm.