Many customers reported issues with food quality, including cold wings, overcooked items, and incorrect orders.
Service Issues
Numerous reviews highlighted poor customer service, including inattentive staff, long wait times, and rude interactions.
Staff Performance
While some servers received praise for their attentiveness, others were criticized for being unhelpful or dismissive.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere was noted as loud and chaotic, particularly during busy sports events, which some customers found off-putting.
Inconsistency
Customers experienced inconsistent service and food quality, leading to frustration and disappointment.
TB
Tabitha Bacon
Jan 1, 2026
2.0
Twice i have gotten hair in my food, once when I ordered from door dash and again a couple of weeks ago, I have waited to leave a review about this in hopes it could be handled properly by reaching out to customer support but after over a week of no response here I am. With a picture of the hair and the email that has been ignored
This is the page I am directed to from the reply to my review
PH
Pat Houser
Dec 30, 2025
2.0
There design team failed. To many hard serfaces lead to over whelming sound levels that can be easly solved. Add some sound deadening surfaces.
GG
Grant
Dec 28, 2025
3.0
Its a sports bar. Wings were mid. Over cooked mainly. Very dry chicken. I like all the tv screens. Many sports options to watch. Bartenders on point.
AS
Ayrek Shoot
Dec 18, 2025
1.0
I placed an online order at 4:45pm and set the pickup time for 7pm. I arrived at 7 and was told my order wasn't ready and it would be awhile I came 10 then 20 minutes later and was told my order wasn't ready. I waited until 7:45 to get my order, 3 whole hours after I placed it. I saw the receipt which was printed at 6:57pm, meaning my order was ready on time but they misplaced it for 45 minutes. My wings were totally cold when I received them, I left a complaint with the manager but I got nothing, she blamed it on the ordering system. Unacceptable service and no effort to make up for it, the placed seemed understaffed too so not only does it take forever to get the food but the workers have too many tasks to provide quality service. Wingstop has better wings that are ready on time with much better service, I cannot recommend this buffalo wild wings to anyone.
MH
Mike Hitchcock
Dec 6, 2025
1.0
Our Last and Final order at Puyallup BWW was similar to the other recent reviews.
Placed a >$100 delivery order for 4 after a long two days working at a children's charity event.
Delivered order was wrong, sauces were wrong, food was inadequate (boneless wings ARE NOT POPCORN CHICKEN), staff played dumb and rude and cheap when presented with their error. Did not offer to deliver a replacement, was not going to cover our delivery fees to replace the food from elsewhere.
This store only has gotten two orders of six correct in the last year, they will not receive our business again. There's a reason that we ordered via delivery, we were exhausted after serving the underserved this week.
It bears repeating: POPCORN CHICKEN IS NOT A STEALTH REPLACEMENT FOR BONELESS WINGS.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Puyallup specialize in?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Puyallup specializes in Buffalo, New York-style wings with a choice of 26 sauces and seasonings.
What are the hours of operation for Buffalo Wild Wings in Puyallup?
Buffalo Wild Wings is open Monday from 11 AM to 11 PM, Tuesday through Thursday from 11 AM to midnight, Friday and Saturday from 11 AM to 1 AM, and Sunday from 9:30 AM to 11 PM.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Puyallup?
Buffalo Wild Wings is located at 13215 Meridian East, Puyallup, WA 98374, USA.
Is the Buffalo Wild Wings in Puyallup currently open?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings is currently open.
What types of services does Buffalo Wild Wings provide?
Buffalo Wild Wings offers dine-in at their sports bar, takeout service, and specializes in chicken wings and sports bar food.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Puyallup?
You can contact Buffalo Wild Wings by phone at +1 253-845-5672.
What nearby coffee shops can I visit before or after dining at Buffalo Wild Wings?
You can visit Starbucks, which is nearby and offers coffee, smoothies, and other drinks alongside their food.
Are there any nearby entertainment options close to Buffalo Wild Wings?
Yes, the Regal Longston Place cinema is nearby where you can watch movies before or after your visit to Buffalo Wild Wings.
Where can I fuel up or handle automotive needs near Buffalo Wild Wings?
Safeway Fuel Station is close by for fueling your vehicle or automotive needs when visiting Buffalo Wild Wings.
What other dining options are near Buffalo Wild Wings in Puyallup?
Nearby dining options include Domino's Pizza, Joy Teriyaki (a Japanese restaurant), Rose Garden (Chinese and Asian cuisine), Quiznos, and Shang Hai Mongolian Grill.