New York Vinny's Pizza

Reviews

• ES

  Edgar S

  Dec 30, 2025
  1.0
  Here’s what about $60 will get you here, seemingly boiled, soggy wings with zero crisp if I had to guess this establishment microwaves them. The pizza is nothing but floppy, no bite to it and after an 8 minute drive was room temperature. I called to ask what they could do to make it right and their manager is out for the night so “sorry for that” maybe tomorrow the manager can call you.
• BS

  Ben Salmon

  Dec 20, 2025
  5.0
  The New York Vinny's location in Lacey, WA, is the best! The food is great and the service is fast, friendly, and professional. You owe it to yourself to start ordering pizza from here - you'll love it!
• CJ

  Casey Jones

  Dec 18, 2025
  4.0
  I felt bad for ordering at the last minute, but the countdown for when ordering closed was reassuring. All the pictures looked so delicious, any pizza that is presented as a pie gets my attention. The menu was vast, and had an offering of unique flavors and topping combinations. As a pizza enthusiast, I am excited to explore this mouthwatering menu. Ordering online was a breeze, with limitless customization options. When I arrived I walked in the store was immaculately clean. The service was quick and friendly. I ordered the bbq chicken Hawaiian pizza, it came out hot and fresh, I eagerly waited for it too cool down so that I could take my first bite. There was a generous amount of melty cheese which the toppings had sunk into. In just the right proportions so that all the toppings were present in every bite. My favorite part about the pizza was the bbq sauce and chicken. The bbq sauce was slightly sweet and flavorful. The flavor was unique and balanced well with the cheese, ham and pineapple. It was a delicious complimentary element rather than an overwhelming bbq sauce. Even the crust was enjoyable, it was soft, fluffy, and glazed with bbq sauce. I’m always on the hunt for the best pizza I can find, and I’m looking forward trying more of the menu. I will be back!
• EP

  Emily Phillippi

  Dec 17, 2025
  1.0
  If you don’t want me to order ahead, then don’t allow me to. I placed an order at 4:30pm to be picked up at 6:15pm. That pizza had definitely been sitting under the warmer since 5pm. $40 for pizza that has been sitting for nearly 90 minutes.
• MM

  micah martinez

  Dec 6, 2025
  5.0
  I have had almost all the pizza Thurston County has to offer. I have had pizza from all over the county, the state and the country. Vinny's was easily some of the best pizza I have ever had. I have had New York style pizza in New York. I have had Deep Dish pizza, I have had thin crust. I have had gourmet specialty pizzas. I have had Fast Food Pizza. Vinny's Pizza was perfect fresh, just as good cold, and reheated was also just as good. This was the first time I have had Vinny's but I am definitely eating there more often. The ingredients were delicious. The dough was "close your eyes and enjoy it good". The sauce was very well balanced. There was just the right amount of cheese. The toppings were generous but not over done. Truly excellent pizza. 👏 🍕