New York Vinny's Pizza

Reviews

• MH

  Miguel hernández

  Dec 27, 2025
  5.0
  New York Vinny’s is hands down my favorite pizza spot in Federal Way The pizza is always fresh, with a perfect crust and generous toppings. The staff is super friendly, and the atmosphere is chill. If you’re looking for a taste of New York-style pizza, this is the place to go 🔥
• JJ

  Jos3

  Dec 27, 2025
  5.0
  Best pizza i’ve ever had hands downs the workers are very friendly i wanna give a shout out specifically to worker Angel for Always getting my Food right as well as Worker steven for being freindly and doing his best
• MH

  mike hess

  Dec 6, 2025
  5.0
  WAS A DELIVERY ORDER.
• SC

  Sharron Clevenstine

  Dec 3, 2025
  5.0
  I had it delivered, this pizza never disappoints
• DS

  Danielle Savage

  Dec 2, 2025
  4.0
  Overall, Vinny's pizza is good. I've had some inconsistencies though. I like a thinner pizza crust, but on occasion the pizza is just too thin and the crust becomes hard like a burnt cracker. When ordering multiple pizza flavors, the crust thickness varies significantly. I have only ordered customizations a few times and each time the customization was incorrect. My favorite pizza is the buffalo soldier (pictured). It tasted great except for the crust. It was just too thin and crunchy. With a bit more attentiveness to custom orders and more consistent crust thickness, this pizza would be 5 stars.