Made the Right Way. Every Day. There's a reason our bagels taste different--they're made the traditional way. At Manhattan Bagel, we give each bagel a dip in a kettle of boiling water, then bake them fresh each morning. That's how we get our authentic shiny bagels with a crispy, golden crust on the outside and that soft, satisfying chew inside. No shortcuts. Just real, authentic bagels made the way they were always meant to be. We kettle-boil our bagels to lock in that shine and crunch, then bake them fresh daily for a chewy, golden bite. No shortcuts, just the classic NY method - done right, right here, every day.
Customers generally praised the bagels and breakfast sandwiches for their freshness and flavor, with many highlighting specific items like the lox bagel and brisket sandwich.
Service
While many reviews noted friendly and efficient service, there were also complaints about inconsistent service quality, with some customers experiencing long waits or unhelpful staff.
Cleanliness
Several reviews pointed out issues with cleanliness, particularly in the dining area and bathrooms, indicating a need for better maintenance.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere received mixed feedback; some found it cozy and welcoming, while others described it as anxious or uninviting.
JB
James Brown
4 days ago
1.0
Was looking for a good bagel place locally. We dined in and ordered a to-go 1/2 dozen bagles. The meal was less than desirable. Nothing to make me want to come back. My wife had to use the restroom and returned stating it was too dirty. The bagles we took home were so hard, impossible to chew, so they went into the trash. Need to find another place.
YG
Yvette A Garcia
Dec 23, 2025
5.0
Had an Asiago bagel with bacon, egg, and cheese and it was amazing! Super flavorful, and the coffee was great too ☕️🥯
DG
Deborah Gilbert
Dec 9, 2025
5.0
It was 5 minutes before closing and they gave us excellent service.
AN
alfia nazarova
Nov 29, 2025
1.0
Visited today for the first time. Heard that this place was good. Food was ok. Latte was great. The restaurant itself in need of a deep clean and touch up. Here is what I noticed while eating my food: windows and glass doors dirty, black paint is chiped all over, some ceiling tiles needs to be replaced, ceiling a/c registers dirty, the spot light over the menu on a wall has stalactites hanging from it. This lack of cleanliness didn't happen overnight, it had to be months or even years of neglect. It's not like I came into a car part store and complain about cleanliness, yall serving food to the customers, yall should do better then this!!!
GO
Gillian O’Connell
Nov 15, 2025
5.0
Food is always the best, the latte is one of my favorites, and Derek has the best customer service I have truly ever experienced!
What type of food and specialties does Manhattan Bagel offer?
Manhattan Bagel offers fresh NY-style bagels, breakfast sandwiches like the Original Bagel Classic, Farmhouse Breakfast Sandwich, and specialty items such as Nova Lox with Cream Cheese and Avocado Toast, along with coffee and deli sandwiches.
What are the operating hours of Manhattan Bagel in Williamsburg, VA?
Manhattan Bagel is open every day from 6:30 AM to 2:00 PM.
Can I order takeaway or delivery from Manhattan Bagel?
Yes, Manhattan Bagel offers takeout, delivery, and in-store pickup options.
Does Manhattan Bagel accept credit cards and mobile payments?
Yes, they accept credit cards, debit cards, and mobile NFC payments; cash is not required.
Is parking available when visiting Manhattan Bagel?
Yes, there is free street and lot parking available near Manhattan Bagel.
Where is Manhattan Bagel located and how can I contact them?
Manhattan Bagel is located at 1437 Richmond Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23185. You can reach them at +1 757-259-9221.
Are there any nearby dining options to Manhattan Bagel?
Yes, nearby dining options include Fat Tuna Grill and Oyster House, Aticha Thai Cuisine, Firehouse Subs, Subway, and Plaza Azteca Mexican Restaurant, offering a variety of cuisines to explore before or after your visit.
What nearby places can help with transportation or car rental when visiting Manhattan Bagel?
For transportation needs, Hertz Car Rental - Williamsburg - Richmond Road and Hertz car rental agencies are close by, which can be convenient for visitors needing a vehicle.
Are there any local attractions or services near Manhattan Bagel?
Nearby attractions and services include the James City County Williamsburg Regional Library System for public resources, Yorktown Battlefield for historical sightseeing, and The Learning Experience for child care and preschool services.
Is there a website or app where I can view the menu or order online for Manhattan Bagel?
Yes, you can view the menu at https://www.manhattanbagel.com/menu/ and order online easily at https://www.manhattanbagel.com/order-now/. They also have iOS and Android apps available for convenient mobile ordering.