Andy Boys Pizza

Reviews

• CP

  Christopher Phillips

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Andy Boys is always a great neighborhood pizza spot. Last night I ordered a pepperoni & mushroom pizza through their online ordering system, and it was super easy and smooth. I also added a few cups of their ranch dressing and I’m glad I did. Their ranch is homemade and seriously delicious… and I don’t even usually dip pizza in ranch, but this one is the perfect mix. When I got there, they were clearly very busy with several other people waiting for online orders too. Even with the rush, the young lady working the front counter was incredibly hardworking, friendly, and professional with everyone. You could tell she was really hustling, and honestly it made the whole atmosphere feel upbeat and positive. Everyone waiting was patient and understanding because it was obvious she was doing a great job. Keep up the great work. We’ll definitely continue supporting Andy Boys regularly!
• DF

  David Feldman

  Jan 5, 2026
  3.0
  I love pizza. I just wasnt crazy about this one. That being said. It all got eaten. I personally have had way better pizza. It's OK in a pinch.
• CS

  Chris Sniffen

  Jan 4, 2026
  5.0
  The food way fresh and amazing. The server was very nice when it came to waiting us.
• RP

  Rosemary Phillips

  Dec 30, 2025
  5.0
  Take out pizza and Greek salad. The mushrooms on the pizza were so fresh and so plentiful. Pizza and salad were spot on.!! We will be going back
• CK

  CrazyCatLady Kelly

  Dec 6, 2025
  5.0
  This was my first time trying Andy Boy's Pizza. Yowza! It was some of the best pizza I've ever had. I first heard about them through FM 99. Well, let me back up a bit ... My husband and I had an orange and white tabby named Andy, whom we often called Andy Boy. He passed away last October and we miss him very much. His birthday was coming up at the end of August (it was the first one after his passing), so I was thinking about him. A few days before his birthday I was listening to FM 99 and heard the promo for the Andy Boy's Pizza gift certificates. The name caught my attention and I told my husband we needed to try it just for the name alone. So I bought a certificate. We live in Newport News; today was the first chance we had to get over to their area. My husband picked up the order and brought it home. We were both blown away by the quality of the food. The pizza is outstanding, and the crust is phenomenal. My husband was born and raised in this area, but I'm from Philadelphia. I'm a pizza snob. I believe a top notch pizza doesn't need toppings to be good. A good cheese pizza can stand on its own, and I always judge a "new to me" pizza shop with how good their regular cheese pizza is. We ordered a large cheese and a 2nd large with mushrooms, onions, and pineapple (along with a few sides). Wow. Just wow! I can't stress enough how good they both were! We liked the one with toppings just as much as the plain cheese. We'll definitely be ordering from them again. I wish I'd taken pictures of the food before we dug in, but all the leftovers are already wrapped up and in our fridge. You'll have to accept some pictures of our angel Andy Boy instead. He would've been begging for some of the cheese off the pizza!

Frequently Asked Questions About Andy Boys Pizza