Paisano's Pizza

Reviews

• DS

  D S

  Feb 9, 2026
  1.0
  We ordered from Paesano’s, and the experience was awful. We even planned ahead, ordering online eight hours early for a 7 p.m. post-Super Bowl start time delivery. At 7 p.m., no pizza. We called, only to be placed on hold multiple times. Eventually, we were told it'd be even longer. The pizza showed up over an hour late stone cold (as you can see fron pictures you can hold it up!) The wings were stuck together. When I called again, all I got was indifference. As a New Yorker, and someone who worked in a pizzeria, I know what pizza is. This was cheap dough, cheap cheese, cheap wings. Their propaganda about being quality is nonsense. Even a chain would’ve been better. This was just bad pizza and bad service.
• TW

  Thomas Watson

  Jan 15, 2026
  1.0
  Ordered this morning. Went to pick up. The delivery guys were there! The employees were there! The manager no where to be found! My order was 40 minutes old he never offered to remake it. Just told me of I didn’t want to pay for a 40 minute old order I should just leave. I would have taken less time if a had it delivered! He showed up in a White T and sweat pants. While others around him was in full uniform, including the delivery people.
• JJ

  Jeffrey Gaona (Realty With Jeff)

  Jan 3, 2026
  5.0
  Had a chicken sandwich which was surprisingly delicious for a pizza shop! I forgot the cashiers name but he was extremely helpful with the parking situation. I’ve eaten from her a couple times and their pizzas are always delicious too! A tiny bit on the pricier side with regards to their pizza but it’s allowable since it’s in Arlington and also since the quality does feel and taste like it’s elevated. 10/10 would recommend!
• SB

  Sean Belanger

  Jan 2, 2026
  5.0
  I love the Pershing location. It’s clean, the people are nice, and the foods great. The pizza is awesome, but my favorite thing on the menu is chicken gyro substitute it with Italian dressing, banana peppers, and olives. By the way they never mess up a custom order no matter how many substitutions you ask for. Highly recommend.
• EB

  efi benjamin

  Dec 24, 2025
  3.0
  Used to order here once a week forever but they recently changed the specials. The sizes are now way smaller but for the same price. Looks like its Papa John's from now on...