Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• CK

  Catherine Kanode

  Jan 28, 2026
  5.0
  I had never ordered from here before and was craving a pizza so I placed an order online and it was ready when I arrived. Pizza was on point!!!!!!! Hot, loaded with toppings, and was a great deal for what I paid. We'll for sure go back.
• MZ

  Matthew Zimmerman

  Nov 7, 2025
  1.0
  Ordered carry out and it said pick up immediately. Went up there and they told my wife it would be forty minutes. Outrageous.
• SD

  Shane D

  Oct 23, 2025
  1.0
  Incorrect hours on app, they cut off ordering at 7:30pm, and they also don't let you order before noon. I placed in order at 11 on Oct 21 to be picked up afternoon, so I placed the order at about 11:30am, they cancelled that order. Then I placed an order at about 7:30pm Oct 23, and they said they don't take orders past 7:30. There hours say 11AM-9PM in app. Plus the people were just standing around talking at 7:30pm.
• NN

  Nardlyone

  May 29, 2020
  1.0
  Went in the Circle K where Papa John's is located here in Amelia. Cashier/cook was not wearing gloves, hairnet or a mask. This is the first day the governor mandated all to wear a mask in a retail establishment. Ordered a well done pepperoni pizza, was not cooked well done with very little pepperoni. I also ordered the jalapeno poppers, since I do love them and this is a new menu item. Opened the box and there was a pastry or calzone in the box. Called them up and they said that hunk of pastry was the poppers. That's always been making them that way. It was nothing but a cream cheese pastry with a couple of sliced jalapenos they put on their pizza. It was awful. Last visit for me. I should no better to expect decent food from a service station.
• TS

  Terry Shaffer

  Feb 5, 2017
  3.0
  Occasionally a long wait

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza