Supremo Pizza

4.7
296 reviews

About

Pizza Restaurant

Details

  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Curbside pickupAvailable

Location

Supremo Pizza
7355 S 900 E, Midvale, UT
84047, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.7
296 reviews
5 stars
253
4 stars
17
3 stars
9
2 stars
7
1 star
10

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Pizza Quality

Customers consistently praised the pizza for its authentic New York style, thin crust, and flavorful toppings.

Garlic Knots

The garlic knots received high marks for being delicious and a must-try item on the menu.

Service

Many reviews highlighted the friendly and accommodating staff, contributing to a positive dining experience.

Takeout Focus

The business is primarily a takeout establishment, which some customers noted limits the dining atmosphere.

Inconsistencies

A few customers reported issues with pizza quality and delivery, suggesting occasional inconsistencies in food preparation.
  • JT
    Jason Theisen
    1 day ago
    5.0
    Take out only, very good NY style thin crust... crispy!
  • JA
    Jake Altizer
    1 day ago
    3.0
    Usually love this place for takeout. It’s my go-to for NY style pizza. But last night we got a really bad pizza. Tasted like a little Caesar’s pizza that had been in the warming drawer all day. Hopefully it was just a one time thing.
  • AB
    Ashley Blaser
    2 days ago
    5.0
    Insane pizza! I am obsessed with their HHR (hot honey ricotta). True NY style. Thin crust and insane flavors. These people know what they are doing! Staff is the sweetest and great pricing! Best pizza in Utah by far
  • DB
    David Bearnson
    6 days ago
    5.0
    Today I got a 14 inch Supremo. It was really great, as was the four or five pizzas I’ve had from them since I discovered them this past summer. They just do pizza right. Maybe it’s the crust. It seems to be the key to their excellence. To me, Supremo makes the best pizza in Salt Lake County.
  • MW
    Matt W.
    Dec 6, 2025
    5.0
    Supremo serves legit NY style pizza! I always benchmark a pizza joint by how well they can do a basic, no frills cheese pizza. The crust is thin and crisp. The sauce is pretty well seasoned with oregano, onion, and just enough sugar to cut its acidity. The cheese blend they use has dry mozzarella. The resulting product has plenty of flavor. With these factors combined, they have all the basics down for good NY pizza! I do have a couple of minor suggestions for the pizza. The sauce could use more garlic, and the pizza could spend a bit less time in the oven. The crust, while still good, is a bit too hard for my personal taste. For all I know, Supremo could be catering to Dave Portnoy fans. Otherwise, it was a delicious, enjoyable pizza that barely cracks a 5 star rating. I'd put it above The Pie, above Slice House by Tony Gemignani, and well above Lackwater. I'll be back for a calzone someday!

Frequently Asked Questions About Supremo Pizza

What are Supremo Pizza's regular business hours?

Supremo Pizza is open from 4:00 PM to 10:15 PM Monday and Tuesday, extends to 11:00 PM Wednesday and Thursday, and stays open late on Friday and Saturday from 2:00 PM until after midnight. Sunday hours are 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM.

Does Supremo Pizza offer delivery and pickup services?

Yes, Supremo Pizza offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.